Pipe NVEG France rules Google must remove offending seach results worldwide

France rules Google must remove offending seach results worldwide

by
in legal on (#NVEG)
France's data privacy regulator rejected Google's appeal of an order to remove search results worldwide upon request, saying Monday that companies that operate in Europe need to abide by the prevailing laws. If a French citizen files a request under the "right to be forgotten," CNIL said
Google must comply with the order worldwide -- not just on European extensions of its search engine
, such as .fr, .es, or .de for example -- or face possible sanctions. The agency denied that it was trying to apply French law on the "right to be forgotten" globally, as Google had accused the watchdog of doing.

Its latest order came in response to the May 2014 ruling from Europe's highest court that people have the right to control what appears when their name is searched online. Google says it has received 318,269 requests for removal, and delisted about 40 percent of the URLs that it evaluated as part of the requests.

Google has argued the precident would leave it vulnerable to similar orders from any government, democratic or totalitarian. "The Internet would only be as free as the world's least free place," the company wrote in July on its Europe policy blog.

History

2015-10-06 00:07
France rules Google must remove offending seach results worldwide
evilviper@pipedot.org
France's data privacy regulator rejected Google's appeal of an order to remove search results worldwide upon request, saying Monday that companies that operate in Europe need to abide by the prevailing laws. If a French citizen files a request under the "right to be forgotten," CNIL said
Google must comply with the order worldwide -- not just on European extensions of its search engine
, such as .fr, .es, or .de for example -- or face possible sanctions. The agency denied that it was trying to apply French law on the "right to be forgotten" globally, as Google had accused the watchdog of doing.

Its latest order came in response to the May 2014 ruling from Europe's highest court that people have the right to control what appears when their name is searched online. Google says it has received 318,269 requests for removal, and delisted about 40 percent of the URLs that it evaluated as part of the requests.

Google has argued the precident would leave it vulnerable to similar orders from any government, democratic or totalitarian. "The Internet would only be as free as the world's least free place," the company wrote in July on its Europe policy blog.
2015-10-09 08:47
France rules Google must remove offending search results worldwide
bryan@pipedot.org
France's data privacy regulator rejected Google's appeal of an order to remove search results worldwide upon request, saying Monday that companies that operate in Europe need to abide by the prevailing laws. If a French citizen files a request under the "right to be forgotten," CNIL said
Google must comply with the order worldwide -- not just on European extensions of its search engine
, such as .fr, .es, or .de for example -- or face possible sanctions. The agency denied that it was trying to apply French law on the "right to be forgotten" globally, as Google had accused the watchdog of doing.

Its latest order came in response to the May 2014 ruling from Europe's highest court that people have the right to control what appears when their name is searched online. Google says it has received 318,269 requests for removal, and delisted about 40 percent of the URLs that it evaluated as part of the requests.

Google has argued the precident would leave it vulnerable to similar orders from any government, democratic or totalitarian. "The Internet would only be as free as the world's least free place," the company wrote in July on its Europe policy blog.
2015-10-09 08:48
France rules Google must remove offending search results worldwide
bryan@pipedot.org
France's data privacy regulator rejected Google's appeal of an order to remove search results worldwide upon request, saying Monday that companies that operate in Europe need to abide by the prevailing laws. If a French citizen files a request under the "right to be forgotten," CNIL said
Google must comply with the order worldwide -- not just on European extensions of its search engine
, such as .fr, .es, or .de for example -- or face possible sanctions. The agency denied that it was trying to apply French law on the "right to be forgotten" globally, as Google had accused the watchdog of doing.

Its latest order came in response to the May 2014 ruling from Europe's highest court that people have the right to control what appears when their name is searched online. Google says it has received 318,269 requests for removal, and delisted about 40 percent of the URLs that it evaluated as part of the requests.

Google has argued the preciedent would leave it vulnerable to similar orders from any government, democratic or totalitarian. "The Internet would only be as free as the world's least free place," the company wrote in July on its Europe policy blog.
Reply 3 comments

Any precedent for this sort of thing? (Score: 1)

by wootery@pipedot.org on 2015-10-01 22:35 (#P6MQ)

Has this sort of thing happened before?

Global companies are used to having to censor for certain countries, but it's quite different here with France telling Google to enforce this right-to-be-forgotten thing globally or else stop doing business in France.

Re: Any precedent for this sort of thing? (Score: 1)

by evilviper@pipedot.org on 2015-10-02 00:09 (#P6V0)

Actually, Google would have to pull out of the entire EU, not just France.

You should probably save your comments for when these stories get pushed to the front page. Here in the pipe, hardly anyone will see them. This is really for editing the story before publication... corrections, more/better links, etc.

Not sure when these will go live... I figured waiting for maybe 3 up-votes would be no big deal, but they've been sitting at +1 for days and days.

Re: Any precedent for this sort of thing? (Score: 0)

by Anonymous Coward on 2015-10-02 12:13 (#P8C9)

Well the issue is not that France wants Google to remove the entries for all countries, what they want, is that Google remove it on all domains inside France.

Currently if you go to google.fr and search one of the remove entries, it will display those results. But if you change the domain to google.com, it will show them.

Considering most people don't use google.fr, google.ie, etc, but use google.com instead, Google's "implementation" is pathetic.

Now we can argue wether it should be implemented at all, but saying that you implemented the request when you actually haven't is simply being in contempt.