Feed propublica-articles-and-investigations ProPublica

ProPublica

Link https://www.propublica.org/
Feed http://feeds.propublica.org/propublica/main
Copyright Copyright 2026 Pro Publica Inc.
Updated 2026-07-13 03:01
The Indian Health Service Is Flagging Vaccine-Related Speech. Doctors Say They’re Being Censored.
The post The Indian Health Service Is Flagging Vaccine-Related Speech. Doctors Say They're Being Censored. appeared first on ProPublica.
How the Trump Administration Abandoned Plans for a Major Cut in Disability Benefits for Older Workers
The post How the Trump Administration Abandoned Plans for a Major Cut in Disability Benefits for Older Workers appeared first on ProPublica.
Young Girls Were Sexually Abused by a Church Member. They Were Told to Forgive and Forget.
The post Young Girls Were Sexually Abused by a Church Member. They Were Told to Forgive and Forget. appeared first on ProPublica.
How Trump’s Transportation Department Is Loosening Safety Rules Meant to Protect the Public
The post How Trump's Transportation Department Is Loosening Safety Rules Meant to Protect the Public appeared first on ProPublica.
New York Moves Forward With a Brooklyn Flood Protection Plan That Falls Short of Other City Projects
The post New York Moves Forward With a Brooklyn Flood Protection Plan That Falls Short of Other City Projects appeared first on ProPublica.
“Ticking Time Bomb”: A Pregnant Mother Kept Getting Sicker. She Died After She Couldn’t Get an Abortion in Texas.
The post Ticking Time Bomb": A Pregnant Mother Kept Getting Sicker. She Died After She Couldn't Get an Abortion in Texas. appeared first on ProPublica.
Gov. Greg Abbott Was Ordered to Release Some of His Emails With Elon Musk. Most Are Blacked Out.
The post Gov. Greg Abbott Was Ordered to Release Some of His Emails With Elon Musk. Most Are Blacked Out. appeared first on ProPublica.
Trump’s Anti-Green Agenda Could Lead to 1.3 Million More Climate Deaths. The Poorest Countries Will Be Impacted Most.
The post Trump's Anti-Green Agenda Could Lead to 1.3 Million More Climate Deaths. The Poorest Countries Will Be Impacted Most. appeared first on ProPublica.
The White House Intervened on Behalf of Accused Sex Trafficker Andrew Tate During a Federal Investigation
The post The White House Intervened on Behalf of Accused Sex Trafficker Andrew Tate During a Federal Investigation appeared first on ProPublica.
What the U.S. Government Is Dismissing That Could Seed a Bird Flu Pandemic
The post What the U.S. Government Is Dismissing That Could Seed a Bird Flu Pandemic appeared first on ProPublica.
How ProPublica Investigated a Bird Flu Outbreak in America’s Heartland
The post How ProPublica Investigated a Bird Flu Outbreak in America's Heartland appeared first on ProPublica.
He Vowed to “Protect the Unborn.” Now He’s Blocking a Bill to Expand Medicaid for Wisconsin’s New Moms.
The post He Vowed to Protect the Unborn." Now He's Blocking a Bill to Expand Medicaid for Wisconsin's New Moms. appeared first on ProPublica.
What the Trump Administration’s Videos From a Chicago Immigration Raid Don’t Show
The post What the Trump Administration's Videos From a Chicago Immigration Raid Don't Show appeared first on ProPublica.
Alaska Owns Dozens of Deteriorating Schools. Now It Wants Under-Resourced Districts to Take Them On.
The post Alaska Owns Dozens of Deteriorating Schools. Now It Wants Under-Resourced Districts to Take Them On. appeared first on ProPublica.
Connecticut Towing Companies Frequently Value Cars Low, Allowing Them to Sell Vehicles Quickly
The post Connecticut Towing Companies Frequently Value Cars Low, Allowing Them to Sell Vehicles Quickly appeared first on ProPublica.
A Tale of Two Terms: How Powerful Figures Were Prosecuted in Trump’s First Term, Then Pardoned in His Second
The post A Tale of Two Terms: How Powerful Figures Were Prosecuted in Trump's First Term, Then Pardoned in His Second appeared first on ProPublica.
FBI Director Kash Patel Waived Polygraph Security Screening for Dan Bongino, Two Other Senior Staff
The post FBI Director Kash Patel Waived Polygraph Security Screening for Dan Bongino, Two Other Senior Staff appeared first on ProPublica.
Firm Tied to Kristi Noem Secretly Got Money From $220 Million DHS Ad Contracts
The post Firm Tied to Kristi Noem Secretly Got Money From $220 Million DHS Ad Contracts appeared first on ProPublica.
“I Lost Everything”: Venezuelans Were Rounded Up in a Dramatic Midnight Raid but Never Charged With a Crime
The post I Lost Everything": Venezuelans Were Rounded Up in a Dramatic Midnight Raid but Never Charged With a Crime appeared first on ProPublica.
How Trump Has Exploited Pardons and Clemency to Reward Allies and Supporters
The post How Trump Has Exploited Pardons and Clemency to Reward Allies and Supporters appeared first on ProPublica.
“Riots Raging”: The Misleading Story Fox News Told About Portland Before Trump Sent Troops
The post Riots Raging": The Misleading Story Fox News Told About Portland Before Trump Sent Troops appeared first on ProPublica.
She Begged for Help. This State’s Probation Gap May Have Put Her in Danger.
The post She Begged for Help. This State's Probation Gap May Have Put Her in Danger. appeared first on ProPublica.
“No Separation Between Church and State”: Inside a Texas Church’s Training Academy for Christians Running for Office
The post No Separation Between Church and State": Inside a Texas Church's Training Academy for Christians Running for Office appeared first on ProPublica.
Alaska’s Public Schools Serve as Emergency Shelters. Those Buildings Are Also in Crisis.
The post Alaska's Public Schools Serve as Emergency Shelters. Those Buildings Are Also in Crisis. appeared first on ProPublica.
Foreign Food Safety Inspections Hit Historic Low After Trump Cuts
The post Foreign Food Safety Inspections Hit Historic Low After Trump Cuts appeared first on ProPublica.
Trump’s VA Made It Harder for Male Veterans to Get Treatment for Breast Cancer. Lawmakers Want to Fix That.
The post Trump's VA Made It Harder for Male Veterans to Get Treatment for Breast Cancer. Lawmakers Want to Fix That. appeared first on ProPublica.
Tech Billionaire Marc Andreessen Bet Big on Trump. It’s Paying Off for Silicon Valley.
The post Tech Billionaire Marc Andreessen Bet Big on Trump. It's Paying Off for Silicon Valley. appeared first on ProPublica.
What Really Happened in Portland Before Trump Deployed the National Guard
The post What Really Happened in Portland Before Trump Deployed the National Guard appeared first on ProPublica.
Appeals Court Upholds Shaken Baby Conviction Despite Medical Examiner Recanting Testimony
The post Appeals Court Upholds Shaken Baby Conviction Despite Medical Examiner Recanting Testimony appeared first on ProPublica.
“I Don’t Feel Safe”: Black Memphis Residents Report Harassment by Trump’s Police Task Force
The post I Don't Feel Safe": Black Memphis Residents Report Harassment by Trump's Police Task Force appeared first on ProPublica.
DHS Wants States to Hand Over Driver’s License Data for Citizenship Checks
The post DHS Wants States to Hand Over Driver's License Data for Citizenship Checks appeared first on ProPublica.
Red State Workers Could Lose Out on Disability Benefits as Trump Administration Rewrites Eligibility Rules
The post Red State Workers Could Lose Out on Disability Benefits as Trump Administration Rewrites Eligibility Rules appeared first on ProPublica.
“Biblical Justice, Equal Justice, for All”: How North Carolina’s Chief Justice Transformed His State and America
The post Biblical Justice, Equal Justice, for All": How North Carolina's Chief Justice Transformed His State and America appeared first on ProPublica.
Details of DHS Agreement Reveal Risks of Trump Administration’s Use of Social Security Data for Voter Citizenship Checks
The post Details of DHS Agreement Reveal Risks of Trump Administration's Use of Social Security Data for Voter Citizenship Checks appeared first on ProPublica.
The EPA Let Companies Estimate Their Own Pollution Levels. We Discovered Real Emissions Are Far Worse.
The post The EPA Let Companies Estimate Their Own Pollution Levels. We Discovered Real Emissions Are Far Worse. appeared first on ProPublica.
Toxic Wastewater From Oil Fields Keeps Pouring Out of the Ground. Oklahoma Regulators Failed to Stop It.
The post Toxic Wastewater From Oil Fields Keeps Pouring Out of the Ground. Oklahoma Regulators Failed to Stop It. appeared first on ProPublica.
Help Us Report on the Impact of Oil Field Waste in Oklahoma
The post Help Us Report on the Impact of Oil Field Waste in Oklahoma appeared first on ProPublica.
Citing Trump Order on “Biological Truth,” VA Makes It Harder for Male Veterans With Breast Cancer to Get Coverage
The post Citing Trump Order on Biological Truth," VA Makes It Harder for Male Veterans With Breast Cancer to Get Coverage appeared first on ProPublica.
My State Banned Vaccine Mandates. Here’s How I Covered It as an Idaho Journalist.
The post My State Banned Vaccine Mandates. Here's How I Covered It as an Idaho Journalist. appeared first on ProPublica.
Senators Propose Sweeping Changes to Generic Drug Oversight
The post Senators Propose Sweeping Changes to Generic Drug Oversight appeared first on ProPublica.
U.S. Postal Service Cuts Funding for a Phoenix Mail Room Assisting Homeless People
The post U.S. Postal Service Cuts Funding for a Phoenix Mail Room Assisting Homeless People appeared first on ProPublica.
Meet ProPublica’s 2025 Class of Emerging Reporters
The post Meet ProPublica's 2025 Class of Emerging Reporters appeared first on ProPublica.
Is Your Medication Made in a Contaminated Factory? The FDA Won’t Tell You.
The post Is Your Medication Made in a Contaminated Factory? The FDA Won't Tell You. appeared first on ProPublica.
Here’s What Happened When ProPublica Reporters Tried to Find Out Where a Popular Prescription Drug Was Made
The post Here's What Happened When ProPublica Reporters Tried to Find Out Where a Popular Prescription Drug Was Made appeared first on ProPublica.
Why Did You Leave the Department of Veterans Affairs?
The post Why Did You Leave the Department of Veterans Affairs? appeared first on ProPublica.
This Is Ground Zero in the Conservative Quest for More Patriotic and Christian Public Schools
The post This Is Ground Zero in the Conservative Quest for More Patriotic and Christian Public Schools appeared first on ProPublica.
Joint Congressional Investigation Launched in Response to ProPublica’s Revelations on Detained Americans
The post Joint Congressional Investigation Launched in Response to ProPublica's Revelations on Detained Americans appeared first on ProPublica.
Ethics Watchdog Group Seeks Investigation Into Border Czar and Contracts Following ProPublica Report
by Avi Asher-Schapiro, Mica Rosenberg and Jeff Ernsthausen ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. Sign up to receive our biggest stories as soon as they're published. A Washington-based watchdog is calling for an inspector general investigation into potential conflicts of interest and ethics violations in the office of border czar Tom Homan related to government contracting.This follows reporting from ProPublica revealing a web of past business relationships involving Homan, his senior adviser Mark Hall, and consultants and firms seeking Department of Homeland Security contracts.The request by the Campaign Legal Center, a nonprofit nonpartisan government watchdog, also cites a story by MSNBC that reported that Homan had taken a $50,000 cash payment from undercover FBI agents posing as would-be DHS contractors seeking his help obtaining contracts.ProPublica revealed that Hall met this August with a company interested in winning contracts for immigrant detention centers. That meeting, at the Texas offices of a firm called Industrial Tent Systems, was also attended by Charlie Sowell, a consultant on ITS' payroll.Sowell had paid Hall a $50,000 consulting fee as recently as February - right before Hall entered the border czar's office working under Homan, government disclosure documents show.Sowell also had a business relationship with Homan. Before he became border czar, Homan had worked with Sowell's firm SE&M Solutions to advise clients seeking contracts with DHS, according to government documents and an interview with Sowell. In June, Sowell told ProPublica he and Homan avoided any conflicts of interest. Tom is an exceptionally ethical person," said Sowell, who has declined further interview requests.The August meeting between Hall, ITS and Sowell may have violated federal ethics laws and merits an independent investigation, according to CLC.When a senior official is involved in contracting decisions that stand to benefit a recent former employer, it raises serious questions about whether government decision making is impartial," the CLC wrote in its Oct. 16 letter to DHS Inspector General Joseph Cuffari.An IG investigation is needed to determine whether Hall's actions violate federal ethics laws." White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson dismissed calls for an inquiry into Homan's office. Tom has always operated with the utmost integrity and is working tirelessly to keep all Americans safe," she said, calling recent reports debunked left-wing talking points."Jackson has said that Homan has no involvement in the actual awarding of a government contract" and that Hall has not been authorized by Homan to represent him.Homan, Hall and the inspector general's office did not respond to requests for comment on the letter. Industrial Tent Systems has not responded to a comment request.Congress recently allocated $45 billion to massively expand immigration detention spaces, including plans to build an unprecedented series of tent camps on military bases across the country. The windfall of government money has drawn intense interest among DHS contractors and consultants, including some with past business relationships with Hall and Homan.Both men are bound by conflict-of-interest rules barring them from involvement in government discussions that could impact their former business partners, ethics experts have said.Homan has said repeatedly that he recused himself from all contracting matters. But ProPublica and Bloomberg have reported he has been involved in conversations with industry players about contracts. Neither DHS nor the White House would provide formal recusal documents sought by ProPublica. In a separate ethics complaint centering on Homan, the CLC asks the IG to investigate to determine if Homan intentionally excluded information from his financial disclosure statement in violation of federal criminal law."The ethics complaint alleges that if Homan received $50,000 from undercover FBI agents, it should have been reported on his financial disclosure forms.Homan has not only said he did nothing illegal, he recently maintained he never took the $50,000.This matter originated under the previous administration and was subjected to a full review by FBI agents and Justice Department prosecutors," Jackson said this week. They found no credible evidence of any criminal wrongdoing."
This County Was the “Model” for Local Police Carrying Out Immigration Raids. It Ended in Civil Rights Violations.
by Rafael Carranza, Arizona Luminaria This article was produced for ProPublica's Local Reporting Network in partnership with Arizona Luminaria. Sign up for Dispatches to get our stories in your inbox every week. Manuel Nieto Jr. and his sister had just pulled into a gas station to buy cigarettes and Gatorade when he noticed a sheriff's deputy standing over two Latino men on the ground.Their north Phoenix neighborhood was on alert. Sheriff's deputies had been targeting day-labor centers in the area and making traffic stops - arresting people who couldn't prove their immigration status. They had one thing in common: They looked Latino.No diga nada. Pidale un abogado," Nieto's sister, Velia Meraz, yelled to the detained men, according to court testimony. (Don't say anything. Ask for an attorney.")The deputy warned Nieto and Meraz: You need to get out of here, now."Nieto drove around the corner to his dad's auto repair shop as another deputy on a motorcycle followed him, siren and lights on, and patrol vehicles swarmed. Deputies approached - guns drawn.Nieto dialed 911 for help: Officers were harassing him, he would later testify in court. One pulled Nieto from his vehicle. Others pinned him to the ground and handcuffed him.Nieto's father came running from his shop.Let my children go," Manuel Nieto Sr. said. They're U.S. citizens. What did they do wrong?"The raid that ensnared Nieto Jr. and Meraz 17 years ago was carried out under a federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement program that grants local police powers to check immigration status during traffic stops and other routine encounters. The Maricopa County Sheriff's Office, under then-Sheriff Joe Arpaio, was among the first in the nation to test out ICE's 287(g) task force program.Since President Donald Trump retook office in January, similar scenes of local officers joining in aggressive immigration arrests have multiplied as ICE has rapidly expanded the 287(g) task force program to deputize local police officers as de facto deportation agents.Moments after Manuel Nieto Sr. stormed out of his north Phoenix auto shop, the deputies left without arresting or citing his children. But Nieto Jr. and Meraz didn't move on. They joined three other county residents in suing the sheriff's office, accusing deputies of targeting them solely because they were Latino.A federal judge agreed that the task force's traffic stops and raids on Hispanic neighborhoods, day-labor centers and other businesses had violated Latinos' civil and constitutional rights. Even after the ruling, the judge found Arpaio continued to detain people based solely on suspected civil immigration violations.The U.S. Department of Justice also conducted a civil rights investigation into the sheriff's office's discriminatory practices, and ICE ended Arpaio's 287(g) agreement. In 2012, ICE suspended all local police deportation task forces nationwide, only restarting them after Trump began his second term in January.Many Arizonans who lived through Arpaio's 287(g)-fueled immigration-enforcement campaign see parallels between what happened in Maricopa County and what's now playing out across the country as local officers join forces with ICE. They also foresee costly troubles for local agencies that follow in Maricopa County's footsteps, including difficulty regaining the trust of Latino residents whose constitutional rights are violated by local officers.The White House and Immigration and Customs Enforcement did not respond to Arizona Luminaria and ProPublica's questions.Arpaio told Arizona Luminaria and ProPublica that he became a target of political persecution for helping enforce immigration laws, which he saw as part of his job.I'd do it over again," Arpaio said. I tell everybody: I didn't do anything wrong. I had a federal court who was biased against me. And all they could get me out on was a contempt of court? Think of that."Meanwhile, Maricopa County continues to reckon with its time allowing deputies to act as immigration officers.Under a settlement agreement, the court mandated broad oversight of the sheriff's office and appointed a monitor to track its compliance. Since then, the law enforcement agency has been required to meticulously document all interactions with the public. In the 12 years since, the department has yet to convince the judge that its deputies don't racially profile Latino drivers and that it adequately investigates deputies' alleged misconduct. Salvador Reza is a longtime community organizer who advocates for day laborers in Phoenix. He said his work put him in the crosshairs of Arpaio's immigration enforcement, leading to his arrest for obstruction during a protest. (The county declined to pursue charges against him.) Because of what happened in Maricopa County, he believes Latinos, including in the communities whose police departments have joined forces with ICE, are now more likely to be racially profiled.At that time, we were a laboratory," Reza said. They did the experiment, and basically now they're implementing it at the national level." Guadalupe, Arizona, where most residents are Latino or Native American, became one of Arpaio's targets for immigration enforcement, which escalated under a 287(g) task force agreement with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. (Jesse Rieser for ProPublica) 368 Paragraphs on Required ReformsThe lawsuit brought by Nieto Jr., Meraz and the other county residents became known as Melendres v. Arpaio - for Manuel de Jesus Melendres Ortega, a legal resident who was arrested in one of Arpaio's sweeps.When U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow certified it as a class-action suit in December 2011, he indicated racial profiling by the sheriff's office had been so widespread it could have violated the constitutional rights of any Latino in Maricopa County, one-third of the population.The settlement contains 368 paragraphs outlining reforms. They range from creating a policy that bars racial profiling to developing a system that collects data on traffic stops to identify disparities in the race of motorists who are pulled over.To end court oversight, the sheriff's office must be in full and effective compliance" with the reforms continuously for three years. The department currently complies with more than 90% of the requirements, according to the monitor, but falls short in the two areas that most directly impact Latino drivers: eliminating racial bias in traffic stops and quickly investigating allegations of deputy misconduct.Snow found that traffic stops involving Latino drivers and passengers dragged on beyond the time necessary to resolve the issue that initially justified the stop."Ricardo Reyes said he repeatedly endured traffic stops as a young Latino growing up in the Maryvale neighborhood of west Phoenix, where three-quarters of the residents identify as Latino. He drove a nice car and believes deputies under Arpaio racially profiled him.They would ask me for my license, they take it and then, You're free to go,'" recalled Reyes, who leads an advocacy group for military veterans. Why was I stopped? I never got an answer."Snow's order requires deputies to document 13 data points for every traffic interaction, including when a stop began and ended, the reason for the stop, the driver's perceived race and whether the deputy inquired about immigration status. The settlement overseen by U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow includes hundreds of pages of reforms that the sheriff's office must implement, including developing a policy to bar racial profiling and to create a data collection system for traffic stops. (Obtained by ProPublica) In a preliminary injunction, Snow wrote that sheriff's deputies, including officers associated with the special operations, circulated emails that compared Mexicans to dogs, ridiculed stereotypical Mexican accents, and portrayed Mexicans as drunks."He singled out two of the deputies Nieto Jr. and Meraz encountered in north Phoenix for making arrests based on race during 287(g) operations. Roughly 77% of all arrests by the first deputy the siblings saw at the gas station had Hispanic surnames, the judge found. The deputy who pulled over Nieto Jr. arrested only Latinos during the operations he participated in.Even more concerning to Snow was that Arpaio continued such operations as a matter of policy after ICE pulled its 287(g) agreement in 2009. In other words, deputies continued making immigration arrests without authority from the federal government. The judge said that violated constitutional protections against unreasonable search and seizures.After Arpaio defied the order and refused to implement many of the reforms, Snow issued additional mandates in 2016. He also found Arpaio and three of his aides in civil contempt of court and referred all four to face criminal contempt charges, a misdemeanor. Another federal judge convicted only Arpaio of criminal contempt in 2017 and was set to sentence him to up to six months in jail. Two months before sentencing, Trump pardoned Arpaio. However, voters had already voted Arpaio out of office.His successors have faced the same oversight and have not fully complied with the court's orders, according to the monitor's reports.Kevin Johnson, an immigration law author and professor at the University of California, Davis School of Law who runs the Immigration Professor's Blog, said settlements related to discrimination and civil rights violations often take a long time to resolve. He pointed to the 28-year-old Flores settlement, which still dictates the federal government's treatment of children in border and immigration custody. There may be complaints about the court monitoring, but the burden is on the leaders and the agencies to show that monitoring is no longer necessary," he said.This January, newly elected Sheriff Jerry Sheridan, a Republican who had worked as Arpaio's second-in-command, inherited the Melendres settlement. He argues the department has made enough progress to end the judge's oversight.Snow acknowledged recently in court that Sheridan and the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office had made significant gains. But the areas where he's not in compliance are pretty important areas," he said.The sheriff's office analyzes traffic stop data quarterly to identify deputies with notable disparities in who they stop. An outside auditor evaluates annually any departmentwide disparities.The latest annual report shows improvements over the past decade, but also that deputies still arrest Latino drivers at higher rates than white drivers. Data from this past year also show that Black drivers, who are not covered by the Melendres settlement, face longer stop times and higher arrest rates. And all drivers of color are more likely to be searched than white drivers.In addition, the sheriff's office acknowledged it has not investigated 640 deputy misconduct claims, some dating to 2015, according to the department's most recent court filing. Snow had ordered that the backlog be cleared to hold the sheriff's office more accountable after he found that Arpaio refused to implement many reforms.Raul Pina, a retired educator, witnessed the fear caused by Arpaio's raids in his Latino-majority school district and surrounding neighborhoods in Maryvale. He has for the past decade served on the court-mandated Community Advisory Board, tasked with relaying to the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office any community concerns about policing that may violate the court orders.Pina says the department hasn't done enough to regain the trust of Latino residents and its deputies continue targeting Latinos disproportionately. He worries that without court oversight, the department will backslide on policing based on skin color.I strongly believe that the only thing holding MCSO back from a very public and enthusiastic participation in workplace raids and other forms of anti-immigrant practices - the only thing holding them back - is Melendres," he said. David Redpath, research director for the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office's Court Implementation Division, discusses data on traffic stops during a town hall meeting. (Jesse Rieser for ProPublica) The Model Was Maricopa County"Nationwide, ICE now has more than a thousand 287(g) agreements with local law enforcement. Half are task force agreements like the one Arpaio deployed.In May, the Tennessee Highway Patrol was carrying out a task force operation in Nashville when troopers pulled over Edgardo David Campos, who had just left a vigil at his church. Campos pulled into a gas station south of the airport, where a swarm of uniformed and plainclothes immigration officers wearing green vests with the word police" on the back surrounded his car. One began to pull him out of his vehicle, a video of the incident shows, drawing the attention of people nearby, including Dinora Romero. She grabbed her phone and began to record.Si se lo llevan, no diga nada," Romero yelled. (If they take you, don't say anything.")ICE touted the Nashville operation as a success, even though the agency's data showed more than half the nearly 200 people arrested had no criminal record.Advocates accused ICE and the Highway Patrol of using race and ethnicity to target drivers in Nashville's Latino and immigrant neighborhoods. One in four residents of the neighborhood where Campos was stopped is Latino. In August, the Tennessee Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition filed a lawsuit against the Highway Patrol seeking access to public records about the May sweeps.Attorneys for the state argued in court that releasing those records would endanger officers. The Highway Patrol and state attorney general did not respond to requests for comment.With enforcement expanding, U.S. citizens have been wrongfully detained recently, like Nieto Jr. and Meraz were in 2008. In May, an 18-year-old Latino citizen recorded his arrest during an operation by the Florida Highway Patrol and Border Patrol targeting landscapers in West Palm Beach under a 287(g) agreement. He was released after six hours.In a statement, DHS said the teen was part of a group of illegal aliens that resisted arrest during a traffic stop." The Florida Highway Patrol said he interfered" with a lawful investigation and was charged with obstruction. State prosecutors declined to pursue the charge, citing insufficient evidence."The Trump administration is trying to enlist even more local officers to help ICE and is offering financial incentives for departments that participate in the 287(g) program. Starting this month, the federal government will pay the salaries of officers certified under 287(g) agreements and offer performance awards" of up to $1,000 for helping ICE with arrests and deportations.Meanwhile, the Trump administration has gutted federal offices that investigate police misconduct and civil rights violations.Advocates say some of the tactics used by local and federal officers to target Latinos in Trump's deportation effort draw from Arpaio's playbook. Raul Pina serves on a court-mandated community advisory board tasked with relaying to the sheriff's office any residents' concerns about policing that may violate the court's orders. He said he is worried that without the oversight required by a settlement order, the department will backslide. (Jesse Rieser for ProPublica) The model was Maricopa County," said Pina, the advisory board member in the Maricopa County lawsuit.The very public, very humiliating, demoralizing approach to the raids, and the cruelty - more than just the images in the television that were humiliating, it was the cruelty - and the violent apprehension of people in front of children," Pina added. All of those behaviors. All of those tactics. They stem from Maricopa County."Arpaio said he did not want to take credit for the Trump administration's work but was proud that deputies under his command were among the first local officers to help ICE make immigration arrests.In Florida, which has more departments with 287(g) agreements than any other state, Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis has spent $245 million to set up a temporary detention center nicknamed Alligator Alcatraz. There, migrants are housed in chain-link cells inside tents. Some have compared it to Arpaio's Tent City," where prisoners were held outdoors in sweltering desert temperatures. (It closed after Arpaio lost reelection in 2016.)In California, federal agents have focused on Home Depot stores, arresting people in parking lots - echoing Arpaio's raids on day laborers. Maricopa County deputies, after getting 287(g) certified in 2007, carried out 11 immigration sweeps within five months outside a former furniture store in Phoenix that was a popular gathering spot for laborers. Snow noted that nearly everyone arrested there was Latino.Trump is creating this complete culture of fear and terror in our community. And I think this is exactly what happened under Arpaio, with the workplace raids and the threat of deportation," said Christine Wee, lead attorney for American Civil Liberties Union of Arizona, which filed the lawsuit on behalf of Nieto Jr., Meraz and Melendres. First image: The courtyard of then-Sheriff Joe Arpaio's Tent City Jail." Some have compared a Florida detention center nicknamed Alligator Alcatraz" to Arpaio's notorious jail, which closed after he left office. Second image: Maricopa County sheriff's deputies check the shoes of an individual arrested in an immigration sweep under Arpaio. (First image: Charlie Riedel/AP Photo. Second image: AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin.) In July, a group that includes U.S. citizens, detained immigrants and advocacy groups sued the Trump administration, arguing that indiscriminate" raids in Los Angeles targeted people with brown skin. A federal judge granted a temporary restraining order, barring immigration arrests based on race, speaking Spanish, type of employment or presence at a particular location.But on Sept. 8, the Supreme Court stayed the order in a 6-3 vote. Justice Brett Kavanaugh was the lone conservative justice to explain his decision. He affirmed the government can use a combination of factors like race and language to establish reasonable suspicion that a person is in the country unlawfully during the operations in Los Angeles. To be clear, apparent ethnicity alone cannot furnish reasonable suspicion; under this Court's case law regarding immigration stops, however, it can be a relevant factor,'" Kavanaugh wrote.Even though the case continues, immigration advocates and the attorneys who filed the lawsuit said the court's action essentially legalized racial profiling.Experts say that approach could filter down to local agencies partnering with ICE under the 287(g) program. When you have ICE relying on racial profiling and promoting it as an effective immigration enforcement strategy, you can expect state local governments that are working with ICE to use race immigration enforcement," said Johnson, the UC Davis law professor.That idea was echoed in Justice Sonia Sotomayor's dissent to the ruling lifting the order in the Los Angeles case. She argued the decision makes all Latinos, including U.S. citizens, targets and improperly shifts the burden onto an entire class of citizens to carry enough documentation to prove that they deserve to walk freely." Sotomayor added, The Constitution does not permit the creation of such a second-class citizenship status."Arpaio said he believes that had the Supreme Court rendered such a decision two decades ago, the Melendres lawsuit and the legal troubles that followed would not have happened.I was vindicated by the Supreme Court," Arpaio said. Everything they went after me is legal."Civil rights experts dispute that, noting that Arpaio's enforcement relied on race alone, which remains illegal. Sheridan believes the department has made enough progress to end court oversight stemming from a racial profiling lawsuit. (Jesse Rieser for ProPublica) It Seems Like It's Never-Ending"As the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office struggles to fully implement the court-mandated reforms, elected officials are losing patience with the requirements and the costs.By March, spending on the Melendres case and the implementation of its reforms had surpassed $300 million, the bulk of which - nearly $245 million - has gone to the sheriff's office.Sheridan, the new sheriff, attributed those expenses to the creation of two divisions for implementing the settlement and the hiring of investigators to tackle the backlog of complaints against deputies. Thirty million dollars has gone to the monitor team since the monitor was appointed in 2013.In 2024, the last full fiscal year for which data is available, the county spent more than $39 million on the settlement. That's a recurring cost every year in perpetuity," Sheridan said. Or at least until the settlement ends.But a report commissioned by Snow last year and published on Oct. 8 found that the sheriff's office had consistently overstated" costs attributed to compliance under the Melendres settlement.Sheridan questioned the report, telling Phoenix talk radio station KTAR that its authors don't have the expertise" to audit a large government agency. He said his office will hire an independent accountant to dispute the findings. There's no fraud here," he said.The Republican majority on the county's Board of Supervisors is calling for an immediate end to court oversight.We just have to figure out a way to end this because it seems like it's never-ending because the judge, they put on a new order, they change things, they move the goalposts, and so we need to resolve this," Republican Supervisor Debbie Lesko, who represents communities policed by the sheriff's office, told Arizona Luminaria and ProPublica.But the decision to end court oversight rests solely with Snow. During a recent hearing, the judge was clearly unhappy with a recent community meeting. The court-mandated meetings provide the plaintiffs - all Latino drivers in Maricopa County - a venue to get updates on progress toward reforms and to voice concerns to the sheriff and the monitor team.At the July gathering, Sheridan's supporters packed the room and took control, shouting at speakers and interrupting the interpreter's translations of the discussion into Spanish. The mostly older, white group of Sheridan supporters demanded an end to court oversight, citing the costs. They outnumbered the Latino community members and activists who want to keep the monitor in place until the sheriff's office proves to Snow it no longer discriminates against Latinos.Snow said he would host the next community meeting inside the federal courthouse in downtown Phoenix. Sheridan also wants out of the settlement. He believes the strict mandates hinder deputies' ability to do their jobs. There's no law enforcement agency that I'm aware of in this country under the same level of scrutiny," Sheridan said.Latino advocates and community members worry complaints about the court mandates and the price tag will become an excuse, distracting from the root issue - the need to end racial profiling by the sheriff's office.When Sheridan tells us that it's done, I'm not going to take his word for it," said Reyes, who endured repeated traffic stops when Arpaio was sheriff. I'm going to wait on the monitor. I'm going to wait for the judge. And when they say, You know what? They are compliant.' Then I'll believe it. And even then, it's going to be suspicious." Chelsea Curtis of Arizona Luminaria contributed reporting. Gabriel Sandoval of ProPublica contributed research.
Arizona Police Agencies Were Once at the Forefront of Local Immigration Enforcement. Now Most Are Avoiding It.
by Rafael Carranza, Arizona Luminaria This article was produced for ProPublica's Local Reporting Network in partnership with Arizona Luminaria. Sign up for Dispatches to get our stories in your inbox every week. Arizona law enforcement agencies are largely rejecting a fast-growing ICE program that lets local officers act as deportation agents - citing the experience of the state's largest sheriff's office, which was booted from the program in 2009 after a federal judge found deputies racially profiled and violated the constitutional rights of Latinos.Even in Republican-led communities known for backing immigration measures, law enforcement leaders are steering clear of Immigration and Customs Enforcement's 287(g) task force program, which the Trump administration is using to enlist local officers in its mass deportation efforts.Of at least 106 municipal police departments, sheriff's offices and county attorneys in the state, nine currently have agreements to cooperate with ICE in making arrests, as of Oct. 15. And only four Arizona departments have signed on since January, amid a national recruitment campaign that has prompted more than 900 agencies to join. The program's explosive nationwide growth follows President Donald Trump's Jan. 20 executive order that, among other things, called for local law enforcement to perform the functions of immigration officers."Local police have three ways of participating in the 287(g) program. The first two are through the Jail Enforcement and Warrant Service Officer models, which restrict local collaboration with ICE to people who've already been booked into their jails. The third way is through the Task Force Model, in which local officers serve as a force multiplier" in federal immigration enforcement during routine police duties," according to ICE.ICE did not respond to Arizona Luminaria and ProPublica's questions.Half of the agreements in Arizona are for jail enforcement, including the state's prison system, the only statewide agency. It signed on in 2020. The Republican sheriffs of two Arizona counties that border Mexico, Yuma and Cochise, signed 287(g) warrant service agreements for their jails this year, along with Navajo County, in the far northeast part of the state.The only local agency in Arizona to sign a task force agreement since ICE revived them in January is the County Attorney's Office of Pinal County, a Republican stronghold sandwiched between the Phoenix and Tucson metro areas.ICE, under the Obama administration, suspended all task force agreements in 2012. The move followed a Department of Justice investigation that found the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office, which had a task force agreement under former Sheriff Joe Arpaio, used discriminatory policing practices including unlawful stops, detentions and arrests of Latinos." In 2013, a federal judge ruled that under Arpaio the sheriff's office had discriminated against Latinos during immigration enforcement operations, violating their Fourth and 14th amendment rights against unreasonable searches and seizures and to equal protection under the law, respectively.I've never been guilty of anything," Arpaio told Arizona Luminaria and ProPublica, despite the judge's rulings. They went after me. But that's OK. And you can tell your audience I'll do it again."Pinal County Attorney Brad Miller, a Republican, said he intends to certify four deputies under the task force agreement he signed in August. Miller said these investigators will process immigration violations involving people they encounter during child abuse and drug investigations, instead of waiting on ICE officers. He said he does not foresee them participating in ICE raids.Miller prosecuted sex crimes in Maricopa County when Arpaio's 287(g) task force agreement was in effect. He said he remembers the chaos that ensued from that" and doesn't want it repeated in Pinal County. We have zero intention and we will not be participating in any immigration raids or task forces. I just want to make that clear."Miller said he spoke with federal officials his agency works with before signing the task force agreement.Would we be required to join specifically an immigration task force?' That was my first question, and the answer came back as no," he said. If that were one of the prerequisites, I was not going to do the program."Starting in October, ICE began reimbursing local agencies with task force agreements for the salaries of certified officers and paying performance awards" of up to $1,000 per officer.Miller said money didn't influence his decision. None of his four deputies will be assigned full time to the 287(g) agreement, he said, only as needed in the course of their other task force investigations.Santa Cruz County Sheriff David Hathaway, a Democrat, believes the financial incentives are a federal ploy to pull local officers away from their everyday duties and direct them to immigration enforcement.I consider the program to be illegal," said Hathaway, whose county shares a border with Mexico. He bases this view on court rulings on Arizona's landmark 2010 anti-illegal immigration law. The show me your papers" law was the toughest state immigration law in the nation at the time. But the Supreme Court struck down most of its provisions, leaving in place only one that allows local police to check immigration status as long as it doesn't prolong the public's interaction with officers.The Supreme Court said this is not in the realm of local law enforcement," Hathaway said. This is entirely a federal issue."States including Texas and Florida have since enacted laws to more aggressively curb illegal immigration. Florida was also among the first to require all county law enforcement agencies to sign on to the 287(g) program. Other states, largely in the Southeast, have followed suit.Arizona's Republican-controlled Legislature this year passed a similar requirement for its local law enforcement agencies called the Arizona ICE Act. But the state's Democratic governor, Katie Hobbs, vetoed it.Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos, a Democrat who runs southern Arizona's largest sheriff's department, has vowed not to involve his deputies in deportation arrests. The county shares a 130-mile border with Mexico. Nanos has said his department is instead focused on preventing crime, and to do that it's imperative his deputies build trust with communities they protect, including migrant ones.The stance we take is: Look, you have a job to do and I have a job to do,'" Nanos says in a video released by his office this year. But clearly immigration laws, enforcement of those laws, that is the federal government's job."In Maricopa County, home to a majority of Arizona's population, Sheriff Jerry Sheridan says he's hesitant to have his deputies certified to patrol with ICE, mainly because his office remains under strict court oversight related to its past experiment with the 287(g) program. But Sheridan has endorsed the ICE program's work inside local jails and said that's where Maricopa County got it right on cooperating with federal immigration enforcement. They're focusing on the criminal illegal aliens," he said of local jail partnerships with ICE. And that's really what a law enforcement agency should be concerned with, is people that commit crimes here in Maricopa County. And that's what I'm concerned with."Sheridan is working to rebuild trust with Latinos that was broken by Arpaio's raids and sweeps, beginning when the sheriff's office entered a 287(g) agreement.For Hathaway, the Santa Cruz county sheriff, lost trust is his biggest concern with deputies enforcing immigration laws in a border county that's 83% Latino.I don't want to have any animosity between the local population and our sheriff's office," he said. I want them to trust us and not think just because they're Hispanic, we're chasing them."
...45678910111213...