Comment 2GE Re: Lots of room for improvement in this poll

Poll

Moderation schemes I like

Preview

Lots of room for improvement in this poll (Score: 1)

by zafiro17@pipedot.org on 2014-07-14 10:48 (#2GC)

The more I look at this poll, the more I realize it could be improved. Oh well! It's perhaps more ripe for a true conversation/topic and the poll just gets it flowing. Looking at it again I see Google+ and Facebook (Like) are essentially the same thing. And I missed the Slashdot Karma system.

I think currently I'm interested in a simple vote up for posts I like, a vote down for posts that are offensive, trolling, flamey, or inconsiderate. And a few tags for things that are useful to filter out (in your preferences you can opt to filter out "funny" for example). Then the Karma system so good posters can get rewarded. But whether to apply global karma (everyone's experience is affected by the group's opinion of a user's karma) or if karma works the way Usenet kill files do, where my opinion of posters affects only how they are presented on my screen? That's an interesting subject too.

So much room for experiment.

How about "Minus one sends a mild electric shock to the poster of the troll/flamebait post"?

Re: Lots of room for improvement in this poll (Score: 0)

by Anonymous Coward on 2014-07-14 14:11 (#2GE)

So what about a forum that allows up/down votes with no upper or lower limit per post which rates all posts from 1 to 10 on scale where 10 equates to the current highest upvoted post and 1 is the lowest. Question is, would the cream still float to the top...

Junk Status

Marked as [Not Junk] by bryan@pipedot.org on 2015-01-03 22:32