Having DKIM INVALID troubles, #2
by mfoley from LinuxQuestions.org on (#54323)
I'm reposting this thread as the previous one was apparently too old for interest.
I have set up a DKIM TXT records at network solutions which is, in part:
Code:Host Domain Name TLL Text
@ (None) ohprs.org 1700 "v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=MIGfMA0GCSqG ..."I have verified with network solutions that the format of this TXT record is correct (but is it?). Doing a 'nslookup -type=TXT ohprs.org' does find the DKIM record.
I have configured opendkim.conf as:
Code:Syslog yes
SyslogSuccess yes
Canonicalization relaxed/simple
Domain ohprs.org
Selector hprsmail
KeyFile /etc/opendkim/hprsmail.private
Socket inet:8891@localhost
ReportAddress sysadmin@ohprs.org
SendReports yes
UserID opendkim:opendkimopendkim is running in daemon mode.
There are no dkim messages in syslog or messages.
dkim is configured in sendmail:
Code:INPUT_MAIL_FILTER(`opendkim', `S=inet:8891@localhost')Using mxtoolbox.com, I've tried to validate this DKIM record using domain ohprs.org and selector hprsmail. It comes back with "DKIM Record Published, No DKIM Record found". Further details at mxtoolbox.com say,
Code:Missing or Invalid Record
DKIM Records are published via DNS as a text(TXT) record using your selector. They should be published at:
selector._domainkey.domain.comI have several hosts for which I'm trying to set up DKIM. All fail to verify with mxtoolbox.com and email headers also show DKIM failure. So, I'm pretty consistently doing something wrong. I've been trying things for month; now time to turn to the LQ experts for advice.
I've experimented with using hprsmail._domainkey.ohprs.org in place of the "@(None)" Host designation at networksolutions, but that hasn't worked. For one thing, I'm not sure what "_domainkey" is supposed to be. Is that literally "_domainkey"? If it is supposed to be substituted for something, what? For another thing, I'm not even sure the Host parameter is where that would go.
What am I doing wrong?
I have set up a DKIM TXT records at network solutions which is, in part:
Code:Host Domain Name TLL Text
@ (None) ohprs.org 1700 "v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=MIGfMA0GCSqG ..."I have verified with network solutions that the format of this TXT record is correct (but is it?). Doing a 'nslookup -type=TXT ohprs.org' does find the DKIM record.
I have configured opendkim.conf as:
Code:Syslog yes
SyslogSuccess yes
Canonicalization relaxed/simple
Domain ohprs.org
Selector hprsmail
KeyFile /etc/opendkim/hprsmail.private
Socket inet:8891@localhost
ReportAddress sysadmin@ohprs.org
SendReports yes
UserID opendkim:opendkimopendkim is running in daemon mode.
There are no dkim messages in syslog or messages.
dkim is configured in sendmail:
Code:INPUT_MAIL_FILTER(`opendkim', `S=inet:8891@localhost')Using mxtoolbox.com, I've tried to validate this DKIM record using domain ohprs.org and selector hprsmail. It comes back with "DKIM Record Published, No DKIM Record found". Further details at mxtoolbox.com say,
Code:Missing or Invalid Record
DKIM Records are published via DNS as a text(TXT) record using your selector. They should be published at:
selector._domainkey.domain.comI have several hosts for which I'm trying to set up DKIM. All fail to verify with mxtoolbox.com and email headers also show DKIM failure. So, I'm pretty consistently doing something wrong. I've been trying things for month; now time to turn to the LQ experts for advice.
I've experimented with using hprsmail._domainkey.ohprs.org in place of the "@(None)" Host designation at networksolutions, but that hasn't worked. For one thing, I'm not sure what "_domainkey" is supposed to be. Is that literally "_domainkey"? If it is supposed to be substituted for something, what? For another thing, I'm not even sure the Host parameter is where that would go.
What am I doing wrong?