Deplatforming Trump will work, even if it won’t solve everything

Less than 24 hours after President Trump was allowed back on Twitter, the social media platform announced on Friday afternoon, January 8, that it was permanently suspending his @realdonaltrump account due to the risk of further incitement of violence." The decision followed several more tweets warning that his supporters would not be disrespected" and saying he would not attend the inauguration of Joe Biden.

The move was the latest in a chain of shutdowns that started after pro-Trump loyalists invaded the Capitol building on Wednesday, and an unapologetic Trump continued repeating unfounded conspiracy theories about the election being stolen.

Facebook and YouTube began on Wednesday by deleting a video in which Trump repeated his claims and told his followers: Go home. We love you, you're very special ... I know how you feel, but go home and go home in peace." Twitter then blocked that video and two other messages for violating its recently implemented civic integrity policy, and locked him from tweeting unless he agreed to delete the videos. Even then, he had to serve a 12-hour timeout before he could tweet again. Facebook and Instagram then announced a 24-hour ban, which they soon extended indefinitely-or at least until after Joe Biden's inauguration. Facebook argued that Trump was violating their policies against real-world harm." Twitch, the streaming platform, and Snapchat also made similar moves.

The degree to which this changes the circulation of information [can be] easily overstated"

Will Partin, Data & Society

Preventing the president's accounts from posting will reduce the ease with which he can spread certain messages, but it may not dramatically shift the online conversation, says Will Partin, a disinformation research analyst at Data & Society.

While I doubt Mr. Trump and his closest allies are happy about being blocked ... the degree to which this changes the circulation of information," he says, can be easily overstated."

Banning Trump from posting on social platforms does have the immediate and obvious impact of decreasing his ability to communicate directly with his followers. But it does not suddenly dismantle the ecosystem of online extremism, or stop networks like Fox News and Newsmax that have fed conspiracy thinking and widespread, growing distrust of government.

Even if it doesn't immediately solve the larger problems leading to this week's assault on the Capitol, however, deplatforming Trump will have consequences for Trump today and in the future, say disinformation experts.

Removing the bells and whistles" of big platforms

A large part of Trump's power comes from how easy he is to hear," says Emerson Brooking, a resident fellow at the Atlantic Council's Digital Forensic Research Lab. Many of his supporters hear him directly on Twitter." And the media expands this reach dramatically: a Harvard study from earlier this year found that mainstream news outlets are the largest amplifier of White House disinformation, since journalists, all of whom are on Twitter, quickly work his statements into their broadcasts," he adds.

That means that losing access to the mainstream platforms will reduce his audience and dilute the reach of his statements, as the deplatforming of far-right figures like Alex Jones and Milo Yiannopoulos shows. Yiannopoulos, who was banned in 2016 for his repeated racist abuse of actress Leslie Jones, complained about the effect that deplatforming had on his income.

Part of it is because people just don't remember to go to other websites," says Joan Donovan, the research director at Harvard's Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics, and Public Policy. Donovan, a regular MIT Technology Review contributor, points out that the mainstream platforms have built in bells and whistles" designed to minimize friction and make engaging with content as easy as possible. If Trump were limited to a niche service with limited design and features, such as Parler, she says, it would create an additional barrier to sharing his content.

Communicating through proxies-with smaller followings

Even during @realdonaldtrump's day-long absence from Twitter, Trump was not entirely silent on the platform. On Thursday, while the president was still unable to post from his personal account, White House social media director Dan Scavino tweeted a statement from the president that conceded the election-but did not concede his claim that the election was stolen. It was picked up by the media, but with 40,000 retweets and 100,000 likes, it fell far short of the hundreds of thousands that typically engage with each of Trump's own missives.

As a result, it is casual supporters" that Trump is most likely to lose if he is permanently banned, says Brooking; they will hear from him less frequently," which could mean that that in time, they may become less wedded to the conspiracy theories and falsehoods that he has made a habit of spreading."

Of course, it depends on whom he's speaking through. Much of his disinformation around voter fraud, for example, came from a wider network of content creation," says Donovan; that is, individuals close to the president who each have large followings themselves, including Rudy Giuliani, Sidney Powell, and Lin Wood, among others. These are the accounts that I'm most worried about, because these are the people that are incentivized ... because they're making money off of this," she says.

A Trump digital media empire" could also be blocked

One route around losing his perch on major social media sites could be for Trump to spin up his own systems to talk directly to supporters. The campaign app for his failed campaign for reelection, for example, had its own news and notification system, which often shared questionable or disproven stories that emphasized the president's talking points.

And back in 2016, when it looked certain that his first presidential campaign would fail, Trump reportedly was already in discussions to turn his massive follower base into a profitable cable news empire. Since November's election, there have been rumors that he might start a digital media empire that would include an online streaming channel.

Even if his deplatforming accelerated these plans, Trump could continue to be marginalized if his channel's links were blocked on social media or if internet hosting companies or other service providers declined to provide him support. After the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, which resulted in the murder of Heather Heyer, website infrastructure provider Cloudflare terminated its services to The Daily Stormer, effectively taking the right-wing website offline.

They're going to keep pressing forward"

After the assault on Congress and subsequent social media bans, Trump's supporters have to decide whether they're wholly committed to violence or to get off the train," says Bennett Clifford, who studies violent extremism at George Washington University's Program on Extremism.

For those committing to violence, Trump may have already become a remote figurehead and rallying point rather than a leader in the ecosystem.

Of these individuals, it really doesn't matter what he does now. They're going to keep pressing forward," Brooking said, in a briefing call with reporters. And it will be more expressively anti-state than it was before, and probably more prone to political violence."

This outcome is not inevitable, however. Brooking says that financial and social costs can become high enough" for the relatively small group of disinformation influencers to stop peddling their conspiracy theories. He counts around 100 people who contribute heavily to the spread of constant disinformation, and figures that without them more Americans will be able to be brought into the fold [of the mainstream] and be deradicalized."

Deplatforming also goes beyond social media. Business groups were quick to condemn Trump and his supporters' actions on Wednesday, and some companies have already taken steps. On Thursday, Shopify, the e-commerce platform that powers over one million online stores, permanently removed two stores affiliated with Trump. PayPal soon followed suit, shutting down the account of a group that paid for Trump supporters to travel to Washington and join the siege on the Capitol.

And the media's shifting coverage will play an important role. While news organizations found it hard to ignore Trump when he was president of the United States, they may find it easier when he isn't-especially if they intentionally decide to prevent amplification of his message, as networks have increasingly done since he began making baseless claims about election fraud.

What then?" asks Donovan. Is he a guest on Infowars?"

A brief return to Twitter

Trump's return to Twitter was short-lived. Thursday afternoon, the president came back online after deleting his offending tweets and serving his temporary suspension, with a pre-recorded video message in which he said he was committed to a peaceful transfer of power to Joe Biden. In the same message, he lied about having immediately deployed the National Guard, when in fact he initially resisted.

If there were any lingering questions about whether his recent experiences might soften his tone, his initial tweets on Friday provided the answer. His first described his supporters as American patriots" who would have a giant voice long into the future" and should not be disrespected or treated unfairly," and his second announced that he would not attend his successor's inauguration.

Apparently, Twitter agreed, permanently suspending @realdonaldtrump hours later.