US policing is far less about fighting crime than controlling the poor | Kenan Malik
Lower-class culture is pathological." So claimed American political scientist Edward Banfield in his 1970 book The Unheavenly City. For Banfield, unlike the middle class, the lower-class person lives from moment to moment... unable or unwilling to take account of the future or control his impulses". Poverty was the product of people not troubled by dirt and dilapidation" or by the inadequacy of public facilities such as schools, parks, hospitals and libraries".
In many ways, Banfield was a voice from the past, echoing the arguments of early 20th-century eugenicists and racial scientists. But he became influential in shaping conservative thinking about law and order, particularly in the attempt to present social problems as the fruit of individual pathology rather than a failure of policy. Last year, on the 50th anniversary of The Unheavenly City, conservative social theorist Thomas Sowell celebrated it as a demolition derby of fallacies that continue to dominate thoughts and actions in our own time".
Continue reading...