Why Red Dead Redemption’s return could be another rerelease gone wrong

I've been waiting to replay this taut, sometimes beautiful western since I binged it years ago. But fans are right to fear that a new port may not live up to its potential

Don't get Pushing Buttons delivered to your inbox? Sign up here

It's my birthday today, and Rockstar has been kind enough to rerelease its 2010 western opus Red Dead Redemption on PlayStation 4 and Nintendo Switch (out tomorrow), as a slightly late birthday gift. It is indisputably a landmark game, less ambitious but also less self-indulgent than its 2018 sequel. The first game is tauter, its crafted set-pieces more memorable. Everyone who's played it remembers that moment when you cross the border into Mexico, and Jose Gonzalez starts to play as the sun rises. Few games boast a single moment that compares to it.

I played Red Dead Redemption the summer after I graduated university, mainlining the whole thing in three days. I remember getting inordinately attached to my horse, the vast desert expanses, the encroaching inevitability of its shock ending at John Marston's farmhouse, which I saw coming but still gasped at. I remember hating the feds with every fibre of my being, and unexpectedly hating some of Marston's former outlaw friends just as much. It was a game with no real winners - still unusual at the time - and took the same bleak view of humanity's essential moral depravity as the Grand Theft Auto series, but with fewer off-colour jokes and more moments of fleeting beauty. I have been looking forward to playing it again.