One step forward, two steps back on CA age bill (EFF Deeplinks Blog)

The EFF has a blogpost looking at a new bill in California that would exemptopen-source operating systems from the Digital Age Assurance Actpassed last year, but has problems of its own:

While the open source exemption, if passed, would improve the law, theremaining amendments proposed by AB 1856 would require all webbrowsers and websites to request and collect users' ages. This is anexpansion of last year's AB 1043's age-bracketing system thatcompounds its constitutional harms to users' speech, privacy, andsecurity.

[...] EFF understands this amendment to exempt open-sourceoperating systems from the requirement to collect and transmit users'age-bracket data. That is a definite win for open-sourcedevelopers. The bill is narrower now than it was before, and lawmakersclearly responded to concerns raised by EFF and the broaderopen-source community.

Some important questions still remain-for example, it is unclearhow the law would apply when an open-source operating system isincorporated into a commercial product or service. And, given thestructure of where the exemption is placed under the "operating systemprovider" definition, lawmakers could stand to clarify that theexemption applies to open-source operating systems andapplications.

LWN coveredCalifornia's age-attestation law in March.