Pulte Appointment Underscores Need To Reform Section 702 Spying
President Trump's highly politicized appointment of an entirely unqualified acting Director of National Intelligence (DNI) underscores why the government's warrantless mass spying power must be reformed.
Congress now faces a deadline of Friday, June 12 to reauthorizeSection 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, an unconstitutional program rife with problems, loopholes, and compliance issues. Section 702 allows the National Security Agency to collect communications from targets overseas - including communications with Americans in the U.S. - and stores them in massive databases. The NSA then allows other agencies, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation, to access untold amounts of that information.
Under current practice, theFBI can query and even read the U.S. side of that communication without a warrant. What's more, victims won't even know and have very few ways of finding out that their communications have been surveilled. EFF and other civil liberties advocates have been trying foryears to knowhow data collected through Section 702 is used in domestic investigations and prosecutions.
Our advocacy to reform Section 702 has been consistent across administrations, including when the federal Intelligence Community was run by people with experience in the relevant agencies. In fact,the 2004 lawcreating the position of DNI - which coordinates America's 18 spy agencies - requires those who hold it to have extensive national security expertise."
Enter Bill Pulte.
Trump on Tuesday named Pulte - currently director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) and chairman of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac - to replace current DNI Tulsi Gabbard, whoannounced her resignationlast month. Pultelacks any intelligence, military, or congressional experience.
William has deep experience managing the most sensitive matters in America, the safety and soundness of the Markets, and over 10 Trillion Dollars at Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac, a substantial increase from where it was just 12 months ago," Trumpwrote on his Truth Social platform.
Because Trump named himactingDNI, Pulte isn't subject to Senate confirmation. And under the Vacancies Act, Pulte could remain in the role for about seven months.
This is particularly concerning because of Pulte's history of using private information held by the government as a political weapon. In his FHFA role, he has accused several of the President's political foes and targets - including New York State Attorney GeneralLetitia James, U.S. Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., and Federal Reserve governor Lisa Cook - of mortgage fraud based on private data held by his agency.
All these targets and others have denied wrongdoing. A federal criminal complaint filed against James in Virginia imploded after a judge found prosecutor Lindsey Halligan had been unlawfully appointed, and prosecutorstwice failed to convince a grand juryto indict James. Pulte's accusations against Schiff, Cook, and others have not led to criminal charges.
Pulte also used his FHFA pulpit toattack then-Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powellanddismantle internal oversight.
Pulte isn't a qualified intelligence administrator. He does, however, seem to be unquestioningly loyal to President Trump and willing to use his position to attack and smear the President's political foes. As acting DNI, Pulte would have access to every scrap of classified information the Intelligence Community holds, and under Section 702, that includes massive amounts of information about Americans.
Even lawmakers who are typically friendly to the intelligence community acknowledge that this is a disaster in the making. U.S. Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., who is the Senate Intelligence Committee's ranking Democrat,told NPRthat Pulte has no experience in the military, no experience in Congress, no experience in the intel community or law enforcement" and was chosen because he is 100% loyal to doing anything and everything President Trump demands."
And Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D.,told reporterswe don't need a weaponized" national intelligence director. Asked about fears that Pulte might pursue Trump's political opponents, Thune said: We need professionals there."
Congressalready has had trouble reauthorizing Section 702as Freedom Caucus Republicans and many Democrats joined forces to demand reforms including the common-sense requirement that federal agencies get a probable cause warrant from a judge before searching any data involving Americans. Pulte's appointment exemplifies why no administration should have the power granted by Section 702 without the independent judicial review required in seeking a warrant.
Republished from EFF's Deeplinks blog.