DNA and Bessel functions
I was reading a book on the history of the discovery of the structure of DNA [1] and was surprised by a few passing references to Bessel functions.
According to Claude,
When X-rays are diffracted by a helical structure, the resulting diffraction pattern breaks into a series of horizontal layer lines." Cochran, Crick, and Vand showed mathematically that the diffracted amplitude on the n-th layer line is proportional to a Bessel function of the first kind, order n:
Jn(2rR)
where r is the radius of the helix and R is the distance out from the center (the meridian) in the diffraction pattern.
The citation for this paragraph is a paper from 1952 [2] that amazingly is behind a paywall.
Update: Evan pointed out something fishy in the expression above: Isn't there a dimensional problem with J(2 r R)? Maybe 2r/R instead?"
This was Claude's response:
- r is the radius of the helix, a real-space length (say, in A).
- R is the radial coordinate in reciprocal space - it has units of inverse length (A^1), because that's how X-ray diffraction/Fourier space works (spatial frequency, not distance).
So Evan and Claude were both right. There is an implicit division happening, but crystallographers do write rR.
Related posts[1] Watson and Crick didn't discover DNA" as is commonly said. DNA was discovered in 1878. Watson and Crick discovered the structure of DNA in 1953.
[2] Cochran, W., Crick, F. H. C., & Vand, V. (1952). The Structure of Synthetic Polypeptides. I. The Transform of Atoms on a Helix." Acta Crystallographica, 5(5), 581-586.
The post DNA and Bessel functions first appeared on John D. Cook.