Seattle ranks 3rd among large US cities in revamped People for Bikes list
From People for Bikes.People for Bikes, an industry-supported bike advocacy organization, has revamped its methodology for how it ranks bike-friendly cities, and Seattle once again ranks third among U.S. cities with more than 300,000 residents. Only Brooklyn and Minneapolis ranked higher. The rating puts Seattle in the 92nd percentile out of 3,422 cities worldwide.
Seattle ranked third under the previous methodology as well, though it was San Fransisco rather than Minneapolis that joined Brooklyn in the top spots.
The new method puts Milwaukee ahead of Portland, Oregon, which may be the most eye-catching result. First the World Series, and now they pass Portland on a major bike cities list? Hell yeah, Milwaukee.
Minneapolis being barely ahead of Seattle also feels about right. I recently visited along with my sister, and that place is just such a wonderful city. It's so fun and comfortable to bike around. It gets a 68 out of 100 versus Seattle's 66, so both places have a lot of work to do. Since it is difficult to compare New York City or its boroughs to most other U.S. cities, Minneapolis has emerged as Seattle's primary foil in the bike-friendly big U.S. cities competition. In a regional context, Vancouver, B.C., remains the leader with a score of 79, putting it as the top large city in North America.
Now, any system created to rate 3,422 cities is going to have some issues. People for Bikes outlines its methodology for those interested. I found it a bit odd, for example, that Seattle's lowest score was a 46 out of 100 for access to major transit hubs." Of course the city can make transit access better, but it is generally fairly good. Assuming every light rail station is counted as a major transit hub," perhaps the dangerous state of MLK Jr Way S is dragging down the scores for all four of its Link stations so badly that it has tanked this entire scoring element. If there were a safe bike route on MLK would Seattle have taken the top spot? We only need 4 points to catch Brooklyn or 2 points to catch Minneapolis.
Seattle's best category was access to major shopping centers," which is probably right. Downtown shopping districts have great bike access, most neighborhood business districts are old streetcar suburbs with quality access to neighborhood streets (as opposed to retail stroads" that are very common across the country), and even U Village is flanked by the Burke-Gilman Trail. We also scored well on access to recreational amenities like parks and trails," and that also feels right.
City rankings are always a little silly. How do you compare Vancouver (79) to Paris (81) or Seattle (66) to Fortaleza, Brazil (66)? Condensing all the cultural, political, historical, and geological conditions of a place into a single number is not actually possible. Even deciding how to define a city" is nearly impossible to get right since some cities include a lot of suburban sprawl within their limits (Denver, Houston), while others only include a smaller and denser core (San Fransisco, Boston). People for Bikes decided to include New York City boroughs as separate cities, which gives more granularity for the nation's biggest city while also pushing other cities down the list (of all the very large cities on the list, only NYC is split in this way). You could instead use something like metropolitan statistical areas (for example the Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue, WA metropolitan statistical area defined by the U.S. Census), but then the responsibility for making changes gets spread across so many more government bodies and agencies. People also typically identify more strongly with their city than with their metropolitan statistical area.
Though the list includes international cities, there are very few cities in Asia and from what I can tell zero cities in Africa. No Asian city of any size ranks higher than Seattle, which seems extremely unlikely. It is a bit interesting to be able to compare a U.S. city to a high-water-mark city like Utrect in the Netherlands, but it's not clear how international cities were chosen for the list, which is heavily dominated by continental Europe. I find the People for Bikes list much more useful when limiting it to U.S. cities since that is the organization's focus and their metrics and suggested actions are designed around the U.S. context. They should probably decide going forward if they are going to fully commit the resources to creating a proper international list or if they are going to focus on the U.S. (or maybe North America) because I don't see much value in such an incomplete international list. Seattle is ranked 286 out of an arbitrary selection of world cities, which tells us nothing at all.
My other thought to leave here is that bike lanes are car infrastructure. As I wrote in that 2018 post, People do not need bike lanes to ride a bike. People driving cars need bikes lanes to protect them from intimidating or harming people on bikes." In the U.S., cars are so overwhelmingly dominant and ever-present that the bike lane network can be nearly synonymous with a city's bike friendliness because any major street without bike lanes will be scary to bike on. However, many other places in the world are not nearly so dominated by cars and have not invested so heavily in car infrastructure, so bike lanes may not be needed in the same way as they are here. Cultural, historical and local economic factors play a huge role in whether a person can safely ride a bike to get where they need to go regardless of bike-specific infrastructure. Even some of the safest and most bike-friendly Europoean cities are removing bike lanes in favor of what U.S. cities would consider radical reductions in car access and speeds. It is interesting to see that the new methodology is responsive to this concept, and so it rates a street's stress level based on speed limit. A slow street (20 mph or less) is considered low stress whether there is a bike lane or not. Mid-speed streets (25 mph) require a bike lane in order to be considered low stress, and higher-speed streets (above 25 mph) require a protected bike lane. This is generally a smart way to handle it, though it does heavily reward places like Seattle that lowered their default speed limits. On the ground, the actual speed of cars is far more relevant to safety and comfort than whatever the speed limit is.