Pissed-Off Judge Orders Release Of Canadian Man Arrested By ICE During Green Card Interview
This is what ICE has been doing for months now. It hasn't been looking for the worst of the worst" because that means actually engaging in targeted investigations and relying on the experience and training of officers to make sure these criminals are arrested without incident.
ICE can no longer rely on training and experience" because those aspects have been sidelined as the Trump administration seeks pretty much un-vetted bodies to hurl into its various surges" - all of which have focused on cities and states where Trump failed to carry a majority of the vote.
Taking down actual threats to public safety is actual work, and ICE doesn't want anything to do with that. After spending a month or so standing around with its hands in its pockets at airports, ICE officers are still roaming the streets, lurking around construction sites, and nodding off in immigration court buildings - two places officers are likely to find migrants, even though these migrants are definitely not dangerous.
And so it goes here. Here's the desperado ICE officers managed to hunt" down in Minnesota by doing nothing more than ambushing him when showed up for a scheduled green card interview.
[Dr. William] Lizardo moved to the U.S. on a student visa in 2019 to study at the University of Minnesota School of Dentistry, according to court documents. He graduated in 2023 and married an American that same year. They had a daughter two years later.
Lizardo's wife filed a petition for an alien relative in September 2023, while Lizardo applied to adjust his status to permanent residency. The relative petition was approved in January 2025, according to the court.
Lizardo practised dentistry in federally-designated shortage areas until his work authorization was revoked, at which time he started volunteering at a low-cost clinic in Burnsville, Minn., according to the court documents.
Wow. What an absolute fiend. Look at this illegal," who continued to help the less fortunate even when he was no longer being paid to do so.
The government argued it had all the right in the world to arrest Dr. Lizardo (not the one you're thinking of, if you think anything like me). It said that Lizardo had violated the terms of his ongoing residence by failing to show up for permanent residency hearings, despite being notified by the government.
The court, however, sees it differently (and far more accurately.) Lizardo did everything he was supposed to do to keep the government informed of his whereabouts as he continued to seek permanent residency. That the government failed to put in the same effort Lizardo did is not Lizardo's fault:
The judge called the facts of the case appalling" - noting that while the couple moved several times, each time Lizardo filed changes of address" with the post office and with U.S. Citizen and Immigration Services (USCIS). In turn, USCIS communicated with Petitioner at each new address."
While that paraphrasing by the CBC might suggest the government was still technically correct, the full court order [PDF] makes it clear the government engaged in opportunism, rather than actual justice, when kidnapping Lizardo following a scheduled check-in with immigration officials.
First off, no one cared about the things that happened back in 2023 (the notices sent by the government to the wrong addresses despite having updated address information) until Trump resumed his control of the White House. Only then did ICE, etc. get shitty about this paperwork mixup that was almost entirely the government's fault. After years of once-a-year scheduling, USCIS decided to file (and mail) a flurry of communications about Lizardo's residence application beginning on January, 25, 2026. Five weeks later, the government unilataterally decided a lack of response meant Lizardo no longer cared to reside in the country legally.
Lizardo, however, did not receive these notices, at least according to the court that handled his sworn statements and testimony. Rather than give Lizardo a chance to catch up with an unexpected surge of status changes by USCIS, ICE officers decided to perform a crime of opportunity:
Petitioner first learned about the NTA, the hearing, and his removal order when he appeared with counsel at an October 23, 2026 immigration interview in St. Paul, MN. Petitioner was arrested by two ICE agents at the end of the interview on a Form I-205 Warrant of Removal signed by David Easterwood. (Exs. A 5; B 4; C 3; D-2.) Petitioner was transported to the Sherburne County Jail where he remains in ICE custody.
If the name David Easterwood" sounds familiar, it's only slightly more than a coincidence. My browsing of Distributed Denial of Secrets' DHS files featured a screenshot of this very person's contact info - which indicates he's a deputy field office director" operating out of the Whipple Federal Building (which is also an ICE detention center) in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
While that's immediately relevant and possibly only somewhat interesting, Easterwood isn't necessarily the problem, even if he's the one making the problematic calls at this field office. What really matters is that any of this was done at all, no matter whose finger was on the proverbial button.
The government argued the case is now moot, now that it's unilaterally decided Lizardo is being held under a different statute than the one he cited in his habeas motion. The court won't abide this procedural bullshit, however, going on to berate ICE for its general shittiness.
Respondents now admit that the reason Petitioner was arrested and detained no longer applies. However, they still insist he must be detained without the opportunity for release under 1225(b)(2). The hubris of admitting that USCIS made a big mistake, but not even offering any sort of relief is galling, although not surprising. There is no combination of facts or legal argument that can support this position.
And while I, personally, would have thoroughly enjoyed another dozen pages or so of the court specifically pointing out each and every aspect of ICE's bullshit, the court isn't writing for me. It's writing for Dr. Lizardo, whose rights have been so obviously violated that expounding on the violations at length would not only delay justice, but possibly allow the government to further delay justice by submitting an emergency appeal full of stupid, self-serving nitpicks.
Because the facts presented here are so appalling and so well supported, the Court could issue a long order, complete with colorful details about, and commentary on, the abuses suffered by Petitioner. However, because the Court is determined that Petitioner will not spend another night in the Sherburne County Jail, the following order cuts to the legal necessities.
And while this obviously addresses the Fourth Amendment violations contained in Lizardo's arrest, it also touches on the due process rights he was denied when ICE decided to do the easiest thing and arrest someone who was attempting to become legally nationalized under existing laws.
ICE agents had no reason to believe Petitioner was a flight risk. He has appeared for every hearing for which he received notice and has never been involved with American law enforcement. He also kept USCIS apprised of address changes, which, of course, is the whole reason we are where we are. He has a family; deep ties to the community, as shown, in part, by his selfless provision of free dental services to Minnesota residents; and a community ofsupporters, including many Americans, as demonstrated by over a dozen letters of support in the record. It strains credulity to think that such a petitioner would flee.
Is Lizardo finally free to go? Well, we would assume this order makes it explicitly clear that he is. However, ICE's new tactic of choice is re-arresting people who've been freed by orders like this one, resetting the clock on due process and forcing arrestees, legal representation, and federal courts to engage in the DHS's sick, cruel game of hide the detainee". If the DHS wins, the person will be expelled to whatever country is willing to take them first. If the system of checks and balances wins, ICE will just rinse, repeat" since it has all the money, personnel, and presidential support it needs to do whatever the fuck it wants until a regime change forces it to actually respect the law and the US Constitution.