FBI Won't Tell Apple How It Got Into iPhone... But Is Apparently Eager To Help Others Break Into iPhones
Remember how the FBI insisted over and over again that the case in San Bernardino was not about setting a precedent and was totally about getting into "just that one phone?" Of course, no one believed it, but pay close attention to what's happening now that the FBI was able to hack into Syed Farook's work iPhone. The DOJ has also said that the crack was limited to just that type of phone and probably wasn't widely applicable. However, at the same time, the Justice Department probably has no interest in sharing the details of the vulnerability with Apple:
Meanwhile, the DOJ may not be interested in helping Apple patch that hole, but it is apparently at least willing to look into other cases where it can help law enforcement break into locked iPhones. There are some (somewhat conflicting) reports saying that the FBI has agreed to help prosecutors in Arkansas try to get into a couple of iOS devices in a murder case there. Of course, it may not be the same technique or situation (and the FBI might not be able to get in, either).
However, this does show just how eager law enforcement is to get into lots of phones, and how important it is that Apple actually be able to protect its users from those who do not have legitimate reasons to hack into phones. It's too bad that the FBI is apparently choosing to hold onto the info that helps it in a few cases while failing to protect the rest of the public who may use Apple devices.
Permalink | Comments | Email This Story
The FBI may be allowed to withhold information about how it broke into an iPhone belonging to a gunman in the December San Bernardino shootings, despite a U.S. government policy of disclosing technology security flaws discovered by federal agencies.Or, as iPhone forensics guru Jonathan Zdziarski succinctly summarized:
Under the U.S. vulnerabilities equities process, the government is supposed to err in favor of disclosing security issues so companies can devise fixes to protect data. The policy has exceptions for law enforcement, and there are no hard rules about when and how it must be applied.
Apple Inc has said it would like the government to share how it cracked the iPhone security protections. But the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which has been frustrated by its inability to access data on encrypted phones belonging to criminal suspects, might prefer to keep secret the technique it used to gain access to gunman Syed Farook's phone.
FBI: You should do it, it's just one phoneYeah.
Apple: No it isn't
FBI: We got in
Apple: You should say how, it's just one phone
FBI: No it isn't
Meanwhile, the DOJ may not be interested in helping Apple patch that hole, but it is apparently at least willing to look into other cases where it can help law enforcement break into locked iPhones. There are some (somewhat conflicting) reports saying that the FBI has agreed to help prosecutors in Arkansas try to get into a couple of iOS devices in a murder case there. Of course, it may not be the same technique or situation (and the FBI might not be able to get in, either).
However, this does show just how eager law enforcement is to get into lots of phones, and how important it is that Apple actually be able to protect its users from those who do not have legitimate reasons to hack into phones. It's too bad that the FBI is apparently choosing to hold onto the info that helps it in a few cases while failing to protect the rest of the public who may use Apple devices.
Permalink | Comments | Email This Story