Senator Ron Wyden Says White House Is Required By Law To Reveal Details Behind Yahoo Scanning

So, one of the things in the USA Freedom Act is a provision requiring that the White House declassify any "novel interpretations" of the law in ordering surveillance. This was to avoid the situations, such as under the Section 215 program, where the intelligence community reads words to mean things differently than anyone else would read them. Now, given what we've learned so far about the Yahoo email scanning case and the fact that it clearly goes beyond what people thought the law enabled, it seems clear that there's some interpretation somewhere that's "novel."

And that means that the White House should declassify the reasoning. Now Senator Ron Wyden is asking them to do exactly that:

"Recent reports of a mass-email scanning program have alleged that federal law is being interpreted in ways that many Americans would find surprising and troubling," Wyden said. "The USA Freedom Act requires the executive branch to declassify Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court opinions that involve novel interpretations of laws or the Constitution and I certainly expect the Executive Branch to follow this law."

This is, obviously, something of a warning shot to the administration. Chances are they'll ignore this, but that could turn into a pretty serious strategic mistake. As we've been saying since it first came out, James Clapper should explain what's happening, because the longer they stay silent, the worse this looks.

Permalink | Comments | Email This Story