Public transport is ditching cash—but here’s why that’s ok
There are still parts of Philadelphia's SEPTA transportation system that accept tokens. But today, in nearly every major American city, you'll see transit riders tapping their way onto buses and subway platforms using their phones. The shift has been swift. Like so many things consumers brushed off as needlessly complicated before the pandemic-QR codes, order pickup at retail stores, grocery delivery-contactless transit fare collection has proved its convenience and been normalized.
What will this change mean for less-privileged riders-those without smartphones or credit cards? Perhaps not much. Cash is likely to remain in some corners of transit systems, says Candace Brakewood, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Tennessee in Knoxville. That's because the Federal Transit Administration requires large urban networks to ensure that any proposed fare changes don't have a disproportionate impact on low-income and minority riders. And the kind of compensatory gymnastics that cities will need to perform to comply with this requirement may actually make it easier for even more people to use public transit.
As bus systems experiment with eliminating onboard fareboxes, for example, operators will need to expand their fare vending networks-which include street-level vending machines as well as national chains like CVS and local businesses like check cashing centers. This is already happening in New York City, which has the largest public transit system in the country.
The city is transitioning from its paper-thin, magnetic-stripe MetroCards to OMNY, a contactless system that uses near-field communication. OMNY supports open-loop payments"-a special card or app isn't needed to get onboard. Instead, you can simply swipe your existing contactless credit or debit card or wave a digital-wallet-equipped device. OMNY also offers a closed-loop" option in the form of a physical card that can be reloaded with cash.
In a statement, the city's Metropolitan Transportation Authority said that it has greatly expanded" its retail network since OMNY cards became available for purchase this past fall, citing nearly 1,000 partners selling and reloading them. It aims to quadruple that number once the system is fully activated.
It's easy to see the increased use of mobile payments as counter to the egalitarian ethos of public transit. But the technology can open up access to systems that would otherwise be difficult to navigate. I struggle to think of a product that is more challenging to purchase when you come to a new city than public transportation," says Joshua Schank, managing principal at InfraStrategies and a senior fellow at the UCLA Institute for Transportation Studies.
Schank, who created the Office of Extraordinary Innovation at the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority in 2015 and headed it until this past January, sees the ultimate goal as payment integration between mobility systems-bike-shares, scooters, buses, trains-across cities as well as within them. But one way or another, contactless, open-loop payment will likely play the role that cash did in the early days of public transit: it will be accepted everywhere.
Rachel del Valle is a freelance writer based in New York.