Trade grades: Devils and Meier a perfect fit, Sharks opt for quantity

On Saturday, New Jersey Devils fans chanted "We Want Timo!" during a 7-0 trouncing of the Philadelphia Flyers. Their wish was granted 24 hours later.

In a mammoth, 13-piece deal, the Devils acquired forwards Timo Meier and Timur Ibragimov, defensemen Scott Harrington and Santeri Hatakka, goalie Zachary Emond, and a 2024 fifth-round draft pick from the San Jose Sharks.

In exchange, the Sharks received forwards Andreas Johnsson and Fabian Zetterlund, defensemen Shakir Mukhamadullin and Nikita Okhotiuk, a 2023 first-round pick, a 2024 second-rounder, and a 2024 seventh-rounder.

To make the money work for New Jersey, San Jose is retaining 50% of Meier's $6-million salary and cap hit. (Meier is a pending restricted free agent.)

Two of the picks are conditional. The 2023 first-rounder going to San Jose transfers to a 2024 first-rounder in the extremely unlikely scenario that it becomes a first or second overall pick. The 2024 second-rounder transfers to a top-10-protected first-rounder if the Devils make the conference final this season or next and Meier appears in 50% of 2023 playoff games.

Got all of that?

Let's dig into the two perspectives of the deal and hand out some grades.

Devils' side of deal Jeff Bottari / Getty Images

Take a bow, Tom Fitzgerald.

The Devils general manager has reeled in the most desirable player on the trade market in 2022-23 while holding on to high-end youngsters Luke Hughes, Simon Nemec, Alexander Holtz, and Dawson Mercer. The kicker: Meier's and New Jersey's playing styles are a match made in heaven.

Meier, 26, is a play-driving, shot-producing power forward who can kill the opposition in so many ways, most notably off the rush and forecheck. He's third among all NHLers in shots on goal and fourth in shot attempts. The Swiss winger is a top-10 player at generating scoring chances off the rush, unleashing his deadly wrist shot often. He's also very effective at using his 6-foot-1, 220-pound frame to sustain zone time on the forecheck or cycle.

The Devils excel at the same things: Smart and speedy, they're a top-five team at generating chances off the rush and a top-five team at generating chances off the forecheck, according to Sportlogiq. What makes the fit even better is that Meier adds a physical, net-front element to a smallish top six.

Thearon W. Henderson / Getty Images

Meier, who recorded 31 goals and 21 assists in 57 games for the woeful Sharks, will be paired with an elite playmaking center in New Jersey - either Jack Hughes or Nico Hischier. Meanwhile, the overqualified third wheel on Meier's new line will likely be one of Jesper Bratt, Ondrej Palat, or Mercer.

(As an aside, don't be surprised if offensive blue-liner Dougie Hamilton benefits from this trade. Meier and Erik Karlsson, a similar player to Hamilton, were electric together in San Jose, working the give-and-go game super well.)

The Devils sit second in the Metropolitan Division with a 39-15-5 record and plus-51 goal differential. They're a superb five-on-five team, dominating both offensively and defensively, and Meier will help a 19th-ranked power play.

Acquiring Meier allows Fitzgerald and coach Lindy Ruff to keep pace in a conference that's gone bananas in the lead-up to the trade deadline. The Boston Bruins, New York Rangers, Toronto Maple Leafs, and Tampa Bay Lightning have already bulked up (and could add again in the coming days), while the Carolina Hurricanes are primed to make a big splash of their own.

As complicated as this transaction may look on paper, for New Jersey it begins and ends with Meier. And through the lens of the 2022-23 season, there's minimal downside. Meier is a true difference-maker, and the package going the other way, while not nothing, is palatable. The Devils want to win now, and this is the kind of home run swing contending GMs must take.

And if Meier - an RFA with a giant $10-million qualifying offer - ends up signing a long-term extension, well, Fitzgerald will look like an A+ genius.

Grade: A

Sharks' side of deal Bruce Bennett / Getty Images

The 2023 first-rounder and Mukhamadullin - a 21-year-old who could blossom into a top-four NHL defenseman soon - are the jewels of the Meier return.

Zetterlund is a middle-six sniper, Johnson is a fringe NHLer, Okhotiuk seems destined to be a third-pair defenseman one day, and the other picks are nice-to-haves. (Of course, if that 2024 second becomes a first, now we're talking.)

Mix all of that together and I don't love or despise this trade for San Jose. The package doesn't blow me away - again, no Hughes, Nemec, Holtz, or Mercer - or feel like a complete ripoff. With a middle-of-the-pack prospect base and an NHL roster lacking star power and depth, Sharks GM Mike Grier went for the quantity-over-quality play. And if the first and Mukhamadullin both hit in a few years, he could look smart in hindsight.

Hired last July, this is Grier's second major trade after sending Brent Burns to the Carolina Hurricanes in another rebuild-focused deal involving salary retention in the offseason. A third such transaction doesn't seem likely anytime soon, as Grier told reporters Sunday night that he anticipates Karlsson will stay in San Jose for the rest of the season. His contract is simply too difficult to move.

That news puts a damper on the last few days before the deadline for Sharks fans, who are probably viewing the Meier return with a shrug or a "we'll see."

Or maybe some disappointment.

Grade: C+

John Matisz is theScore's senior NHL writer. Follow John on Twitter (@MatiszJohn) or contact him via email (john.matisz@thescore.com).

Copyright (C) 2023 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.