Is Poor Things a feminist film? Is Barbie? These have become meaningless questions | Beatrice Loayza

The label of feminist' is beginning to feel more like a subcategory on Netflix than a meaningful description of art

Let's play a game. Of all the best picture nominees from this year's Oscars, which film is the most feminist? Is it Barbie, a family-friendly paean to our childhood's plastic It Girl? Poor Things, a racy riff on Frankenstein that charts one woman's process of self-emancipation? Or is it Anatomy of a Fall, about a hotshot bisexual writer accused of murdering her man?

You can make a solid case for any one of them. Conversely, a takedown of each is easy, too. Barbie's girl power is nothing but good PR for Mattel, and besides, why did they allow Ryan Gosling to steal the show? Poor Things is a man's manicured vision of women's liberation. If it's so feminist, where's the menstrual blood? The armpit hair?

Beatrice Loayza is a film critic and historian based in New York

Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.