Palworld Creator Loves That Others Are Trying To Clone The Game
We've had several posts on the video game sensation that is Palworld in the past. Given that the game has been described by others as Pokemon, but with guns", we kicked things off both wondering if Nintendo was going to try to take some kind of misguided legal action on the game, while also pointing out that the game is an excellent case study in copyright's idea/expression dichotomy. After all, the game does not do any direct copying of any Pokemon IP, but does draw obvious inspiration from some of the base ideas behind that IP. In fact, highlighting the dichotomy further was a mod that injected actual Pokemon IP into Palworld, which Nintendo then managed to get taken down.
One of the things writers of this sort of content like me tend to fret about, however, is how often rank hypocrisy suddenly shows up among subjects such as the creators behind Palworld. It's not uncommon to see a content creator attempt to go after folks doing to them exactly what the creator did in drawing inspiration from others. If you were worried the people behind Palworld would fall into this category, however, it appears very much that you were worried for nothing.
With the success of the game, it was only a matter of time before someone, or many someones, tried to cash in on its success by making similar games, or clones." PocketPair CEO Takuro Mizobe noticed this was happening with Palworld and reacted thusly.
Tencent is already making a Palworld clone game!" PocketPair CEO Takuro Mizobe recently tweeted," according to atranslation byAutomaton. He seemed happy about it. These are incredible times," he wrote. Some initially interpreted Mizobe as being critical of these moves.AnIGNstorydescribed him as accusing other companies of ripping offPalworld, a framing the CEO rejected.
To accuse' someone of something, means to say they are doing something wrong," Mizobewrote in a follow-up tweetresponding to theIGNstory. I don't think what Tencent is doing is wrong. I'm proud that other companies want to make games likePalworld. The industry historically innovates when we borrow ideas from games we love. I'm surprised that many high-quality mobile games are already in development."
No going legal. No threats. Not even a hint of a complaint. Instead, Mizobe acknowledged what we all already know to be true: video games, like other forms of culture, are and have always been built on what came before it. If the success of Palworld spawns similar games after the fact, that's not only not a problem, it's a good thing for gaming culture. Hell, Mizobe even went so far as to praise some of these games' quality.
Imagine Nintendo doing anything like this. You simply can't. In fact, when Palworld was released, Nintendo made some vague comments about looking into the game to see if it wanted to pursue any legal action. You know, the exact opposite of the route Mizobe took.
Who knows if these newPalworldclones that Tencent and others are apparently developing will ever see the light of day. We won't know if they're actually rip-offs until they're out, but Mizobe doesn't seem to mind either way.
And why should he? I imagine he's far too busy counting all the money his company is making by focusing on making a successful game rather than wringing his hands over some clones that may or may not ever gain any traction.