Apple Dumps Suit Against NSO Group After Israeli Government Walks Off With A Bunch Of The Company’s Files
Well, it worked. We'll have to see how this plays out in the lawsuit WhatsApp brought against NSO Group, but it has managed to shed one litigant thanks to intervention from the home team: the Israeli government.
In July, documents obtained by Distributed Denial of Secrets (DDoS) revealed the desperate measures NSO Group deployed to avoid having to turn over internal information during discovery in multiple lawsuits, including one filed by Apple. Knowing that discovery was inevitable, NSO met with Israeli government officials and asked them to secure a blocking order from the nation's courts to prevent having to comply with discovery requests.
The government secured these orders and went to work shortly after WhatsApp served NSO with its discovery requests. According to the paperwork, the government needed to seize a bunch of the company's internal documents for national security" reasons, speculating disingenuously and wildly that turning over any information about NSO's Pegasus phone-hacking malware would make the nation itself less secure.
Shortly thereafter, the Israeli government engaged in a performative raid of NSO's offices to seize anything NSO felt might be disadvantageous in these lawsuits. WhatsApp is still in the litigation game, hoping to obtain anything the Israeli government hasn't already seized that might relate to its claims of unauthorized access by NSO customers deploying Pegasus malware via the company's US servers.
Apple, however, has decided it's not going to spend any more money or time trying to win a rigged game, as Joseph Menn reports for the Washington Post.
Apple asked a court Friday to dismiss itsthree-year-old hacking lawsuitagainst spyware pioneer NSO Group, arguing that it might never be able to get the most critical files about NSO's Pegasus surveillance tool and that its own disclosures could aid NSO and its increasing number of rivals.
[...]
While Apple takes no position on the truth or falsity of the Guardian Story described above, its existence presents cause for concern about the potential for Apple to obtain the discovery it needs," the iPhone maker wrote in its filing Friday. Israeli officials have not disputed the authenticity of the documents but havedeniedinterfering in the U.S. litigation.
As for that last sentence, that's a dodge. Of course the Israeli government interfered with this litigation. That it didn't actually insert itself directly into either of these bases doesn't change the fact that the raid it performed because NSO Group asked it to means the company no longer has the documents sought by US litigants in its possession.
The more surprising assertion is Apple's: that part of its reason for dropping the lawsuit is to avoid having to turn over any of its own stuff in response to discovery requests. But the rationale is very much an Apple thing: the company feels giving more information to NSO - especially in open court - will just be used to facilitate the creation of new hacking tools for NSO (or its competitors) to use against Apple's customers.
That's more of a concern for Apple, which is seeking to protect an entire operating system. WhatsApp's concerns are more limited. While it too would probably prefer any information it hands over in court not be used against it by malware merchants, it only has to worry about a single service, rather than the underlying infrastructure (so to speak) shared by dozens of Apple products.
Discovery is underway in the WhatsApp case, so hopefully we'll be seeing some interesting developments there soon. But given what's happened here, NSO and its Israel-based competitors have some really interesting (and disturbing) options when it comes to thwarting lawsuits over the constant abuse of its Pegasus malware.