Kneejerk response, then overcorrection: what the aftermath of the Amsterdam violence should teach us | Rachel Shabi

Assumptions were made about clashes between Maccabi Tel Aviv fans and Amsterdam locals - and the far right took advantage

In the aftermath of a sudden eruption of violence or unrest, there is often a brief, vital window when the narrative about what actually happened is up for grabs. Last Friday, the day that street violence between Israeli Maccabi Tel Aviv football fans and local people in Amsterdam made headlines around the world - with reports of antisemitic hit-and-run" attacks in the Dutch city - the decision of the Israeli state to send military planes to airlift fans home, and of the Israeli president, Isaac Herzog, to describe the events as an antisemitic pogrom", were crucial in cementing a particular story. So too were the words of the Dutch king, who said that his nation had failed" the Jewish community as it had during the second world war - when three-quarters of the Dutch Jewish population were murdered by the Nazis.

But then, as more evidence emerged, a more complex picture came into view. It was revealed that from the night before the match onwards, hardline supporters of Maccabi Tel Aviv - a club with a reputation for racism and hooliganism among some of its fans - had torn down a Palestinian flag from the facade of a building and burned it, attacked one taxi with their belts, and vandalised others. Among the deplorable chants they saw fit to shout on the streets of Amsterdam, home to a large Muslim community, were: Let the IDF [Israeli army] win, we will fuck the Arabs", Fuck you Palestine" and Why is there no school in Gaza? There are no children left there."