What is a ‘criminal’ immigrant? The word is an American rhetorical trap | Jonathan Ben-Menachem
Allegations of criminality have always been deployed to justify state violence but even imperfect' victims deserve basic rights
Last month, the Trump administration flew 238 Venezuelan immigrants to a brutal prison in El Salvador. Federal officials alleged that the detainees were members of the Tren de Aragua gang, calling them heinous monsters" ,criminal aliens", the worst of the worst". The federal government has also revoked visas for a thousand international students over their alleged participation in protests against Israel's genocide in Palestine. Some were abducted, like Mahmoud Khalil, who has spent more than a month incarcerated in one of the worst jails in the US. Officials alleged that Mahmoud sided with terrorists ... who have killed innocent men, women, and children".
Media reports quickly revealed that the Trump administration is lying about innocent" people to justify abducting them. But this raises a more important question: if Trump's victims weren't innocent", does that make them disposable? I worry that emphasizing the innocence of victims creates a rhetorical trap. It's like carefully digging a pit that the fascists can shove us into.
Continue reading...