Ranking the Detroit Lions offensive players into tiers

DETROIT, MICHIGAN - DECEMBER 21: A rear view of Jared Goff #16 of the Detroit Lions as he huddles with his teammates during the game against the Pittsburgh Steelers at Ford Field on December 21, 2025 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by Nic Antaya/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The Detroit Lions heading into free agency with plenty of needs on the horizon and a challenging amount of resources both in free agency and the NFL Draft. But before the Lions can go on a shopping spree to make a run at the Super Bowl next season, they need to properly assess their own roster. Self-scouting is an essential part of the process in order to decide which players should return in 2026 and which positions need a serious upgrade.

So on this week's PODcast, we do the same. We evaluate the Detroit Lions' players on offense, placing them into seven different tiers:

• Solidified All-Pro talent
• Good player, could be elite
• Starter
• Depth, could challenge for starter
• Depth, nothing more, nothing less
• Developmental depth
• Time to move on

This wasn't an exhaustive list of players on the Lions' offensive roster, but we discuss the futures of players like Giovanni Manu, David Montgomery, Graham Glasgow, Kalif Raymond, and Miles Frazier and how Detroit's decisions on those players will shape their entire offseason plan. We also have more fun, but less meaningful, debates like: Does Jared Goff belong in the same tier as Amon-Ra St. Brown, Jahmyr Gibbs, and Penei Sewell? Does Tate Ratledge have elite" potential?

In the end, this is the tier-list we came up with:

You can make your own tier list here, and be sure to share it with us on social media or in the comment section below!

Other topics on this week's PODcast include:

• Levi Onwuzurike and Josh Paschal are back! Is this good news, and how does it impact the Lions' offseason?
• Debating whether the Lions will win any NFL Honors awards
• The NFC North brain drain may be coming for the Vikings, Packers, and Bears

You can listen to the entire show in the embedded player below or by searching Pride of Detroit" on your favorite podcasting platform.

If you want to catch the video version of the PODcast, head to our YouTube page or Twitch channel.