Kash Patel’s ‘Leadership’ Is Pretty Much Just Libel Lawsuits And Lie Detectors
Kash Patel is one of the rare Trump political appointees who actually has some experience that might be useful in his current position. But it wasn't his past experience as a federal public defender and prosecutor that prompted Trump to elevate him to the post of FBI Director. Instead, it was his willingness to engage in politically motivated investigations, along with his willingness to host pro-MAGA podcasts when their original hosts were in prison on federal charges.
Patel serves at the president's pleasure, as all political appointees do. But Trump's pleasure is more unpredictable than most. Perhaps realizing his time frame for making hay is extremely short, Patel has done very little in terms of leadership, preferring to spend his time (allegedly) partying it up when not (allegedly) failing to gain the trust and respect of the Bureau.
When not saying stupid things on social media or during press conferences, Patel likes to leverage his position to do things like... hang out in the US Olympic hockey team locker room as they celebrated their gold medal win.
Consequently, plenty has been published about Patel's (alleged) inability to stay sober and/or do his damn job. A shocking expose of Patel's (alleged) constant insobriety prompted Patel to respond in the fashion he's been accustomed to during his tenure as FBI Director. He filed a libel lawsuit against The Atlantic over its reporting on his months of (allegedly) unprofessional behavior.
Hilariously, Patel and his lawyers relied on a previous lawsuit he had filed against MSNBC for its earlier reporting on pretty much the same subject, taking particular objection to this statement made by reporter Frank Figliuzzi:
Yeah, well, reportedly, he's been visible at nightclubs far more than he has been on the seventh floor of the Hoover building.
Perhaps he should have waited until his first lawsuit had been fully litigated. The lawsuit he used as part of his arguments in favor of actual malice" was dismissed, with the judge finding in favor of MSNBC and Figliuzzi.
So, this is one the things Patel seems to be involved in daily, which isn't actually a part of his day-to-day duties as FBI Director. The other thing he seems to be doing on a regular basis is ensuring the people who still work for him won't want to work for him for much longer.
FBI Director Kash Patel ordered the polygraphing of more than two dozen former and current members of his security detail, as well as other staff, and has been described as being in panic mode to save his job and find leakers among his team, according to two people briefed on the development.
[...]
The director has also avoided meeting this week with some key operational leaders of the bureau, the people said, raising concerns inside the FBI about Patel's ability to stay abreast of pressing threats and investigations in order to make the best decisions.
Will this reporting prompt another lawsuit from Kash Patel? I would hope his lawyers are smarter than Patel appears to be, because going back to the same well so quickly following a libel lawsuit loss might add sanctions to the humiliation of another public loss in a federal court.
The funniest thing about this reporting is that the FBI official spokesman, Ben Williamson, refused to deny the use of polygraph tests, instead deciding to deny the assertion that Patel isn't regularly attending meetings with key FBI officials. It's not like Williamson couldn't have just lied about the polygraphs. This is an administration that is willing to lie about pretty much anything at any time. Having their lies exposed doesn't regularly result in firing, which means blatantly lying has nearly no professional consequences. But Williamson just decided to ignore a question he didn't want to answer.
The refusal to even address this claim implies that it's true. And why shouldn't it be? This is nothing new for Kash Patel and his particular version of the FBI:
Since Kash Patel took office as the director of the F.B.I., the bureau has significantly stepped up the use of the lie-detector test, at times subjecting personnel to a question as specific as whether they have cast aspersions on Mr. Patel himself.
In interviews and polygraph tests, the F.B.I. has asked senior employees whether they have said anything negative about Mr. Patel, according to two people with knowledge of the questions and others familiar with similar accounts. In one instance, officials were forced to take a polygraph as the agency sought to determine who disclosed to the news media that Mr. Patel had demanded a service weapon, an unusual request given that he is not an agent. The number of officials asked to take a polygraph is in the dozens, several people familiar with the matter said, though it is unclear how many have specifically been asked about Mr. Patel.
Those were the (alleged) facts on the ground as of July 2025. Since then, Patel hasn't done much to distance himself from allegations of misusing his position for personal gain, whether it's trying to get special treatment from the Bureau itself, or crashing Olympic celebrations just because he can.
I find it hard to believe even Patel himself thinks he's actually leading the FBI. After all, this is the same guy who (allegedly!) thought he'd been fired when he bungled one too many login attempts. But he's the perfect guy for the Trump administration: someone who spreads falsehoods, yells fake news" whenever publicly criticized, files lost-cause lawsuits against people protected by the First Amendment, and will quietly accept his dismissal whenever Trump decides to turn on him.