Article 79TX0 Vice-President Grassley And The Bipartisan Politics Of An Imminent Trump Impeachment

Vice-President Grassley And The Bipartisan Politics Of An Imminent Trump Impeachment

by
Cathy Gellis
from Techdirt on (#79TX0)

There was always a deal to be made similar to the one that is described here, had Democrat leadership ever had the vision, skill, and courage to pursue it. But now, after the last election, it is even easier to play the political musical chairs that impeachment would involve, and to everyone's satisfaction.

There never was a reason to wait to impeach Trump, and there certainly isn't one at this point. There is plenty of evidence upon which to predicate it (pretty much any two Truth Social posts would provide sufficient basis), and the Constitution requires little more than two votes on it: one in the House to impeach, and one in the Senate to convict. Trump could be gone in a day, and given all the damage he causes every minute he remains, there is no time to lose to get started.

One of the main arguments people have nevertheless put forth to try to justify the Democrats' refusal to pursue impeachment against Trump has been they don't have the votes." Already it was a ridiculous argument: in the House, if the Democratic caucus had been united in pursuing it, they would have only needed to peel off a few Republicans to come join them, and, depending on absences, potentially very few. And had the Democrats been united behind impeachment it would have changed the political math enough for the GOP to think seriously about joining them-whereas given the Democrats abject refusal to get on board with it there was never any reason for any Republican to ever even consider it either.

(Meanwhile, even if Democrats were somehow correct to have been deterred from moving forward with an actual impeachment attempt, the numbers certainly didn't justify not even beginning to pound the drum on eventually impeaching. After all, if you don't have the votes today, the job is to work towards getting them tomorrow. And then using them once you do, as they most definitely do now.)

Still, while having enough votes in the House is not an issue-come January the Democrats will have plenty of their own, without needing GOP help-there is still the question of the Senate, which is what this post is about. Like with the House getting the votes needed to convict and actually remove Trump always was possible, if only Democrat leadership had the vision to see it. And now, after the election, it is even more possible, if only Democrats would finally do what is needed to line them up.

Obviously at 56 Senators (or 55 with the Fetterman discount) Democrats cannot vote to remove Trump from office by themselves. But there has always been a deal to be done, which is now even easier to do, to get Republicans on board by making it worth their while politically. Especially after the drubbing this November even the most politically obtuse Republicans must understand that Trump is an albatross hanging around their neck, destroying their political futures and the prospects for any policy they hoped to advance. While they might have been afraid to try to make a move against Trump before November, fearing his cult-like popularity would make it impossible to politically survive such an attempt, they now know that his popularity is at best fragile if not illusory. Even many MAGA adherents, even if still generally on Team Trump, have been openly speaking about their dismay in him not delivering on what he promised (and instead delivering the exact opposite). In any case, there is now evidence of a nation-wide appetite to be done with Trump, which everyone, including and especially the Senators up for reelection in 2028, both Republican AND Democrat, needs to heed. Their future political fortunes depend on it, and everyone now knows it.

But for Republicans, their political interests are not just limited to being rid of Trump. Impeachment also creates political opportunity due to all the vacancies it creates, starting in the Presidency itself. With the Presidency empty, the Vice President is automatically promoted into it, which then leaves the Vice Presidency empty and waiting to be filled. Which is where things get interesting, because it is not filled automatically but by presidential appointment. And if it's filled with a sitting Senator, then it also creates an opportunity to appoint another to replace them in the Senate. Thus it is time for Democrat leaders with vision to start choreographing the political dance that impeachment could soon have everyone on both sides of the aisle moving to.

Obviously whether such a deal should be seen as a win for Democrats and the country depends on accepting one thing: that just about any alternative is better than Trump. Even the most craven and crooked Republican is still better than Trump, who is corrupt on a scale even regularly corrupt politicians could hardly imagine. Even the most sinister and cynical Republican is still better than Trump because, unlike Trump, they don't have a cult of personality to fuel their administration's malevolence. And the reality remains: Trump is a volatile, reckless, exigent, and uncontained threat to the security of the nation every moment he remains in office. Any alternative who is even slightly less of a danger is a necessary and imminently needed improvement.

Which is why, yes, even J.D. Vance is still an improvement, awful though he is. He is at least a little smarter, and also less popular, which means people will be able to say no to him where they have been unable to say no to Trump. But there is also an opportunity here: if the Democrats play their cards right there is a chance that instead of just a bad but better deal that elevates Vance, they could get one that brings them even more advantage.

Any deal of course does begin with Vance. He obviously has aspirations for the Oval Office, and since the election has shown himself willing to knife Trump. He is, for purposes of saving our democracy from Trump, an available ally, however inadvertently, for Democrats who are serious about that country-saving mission to work with. And there is a definitely a deal to be made with him: help him get his dream job in exchange for his agreement on policy that Democrats are obviously not going to be able to get from Trump and his vindictive veto (no matter how much they delude themselves to the contrary).

The downside to this deal-apart from just having to live with President Vance for two years-is that there is a presumed incumbent advantage come the next presidential election, but a strong Democratic majority can keep him on a short enough leash to keep the political momentum for Democrats heading into 2028. (Whereas refusing to anything about the Trump problem essentially crashes the momentum into a wall-why should anyone reward Democrats with more power ever again when they are content to use what they have to so willingly surrender the country to Putin's puppet?). Also, this is VANCE that we're talking about, someone whom people have rarely ever actually wanted to vote for, which is unlikely to change after the public sees him in action. Which is also why this deal may start to be palatable to Republicans as well, particularly those with their own presidential ambitions that an incumbent Vance is unlikely to obstruct.

Especially because there is a more immediate benefit for Republicans, whose votes are still needed for removal, if the right deal is done. Vance's promotion would leave a vacancy in the Vice Presidency. There is no automatic successor, which means that filling the office requires a Presidential appointment. So part of the deal to elevate Vance would involve pre-emptively deciding whom Vance would appoint to replace him. And it could entice impeachment votes if that choice is a GOP Senator.

From the standpoint of defending the nation, ANY GOP Senator would do, but if the Democrats can present a strong front, they can probably make a strategic suggestion on whom that GOP Senator should be. And someone like Iowa Senator Grassley would be a good choice, for both parties, for several reasons.

From the Republican perspective, in light of his age, he will not have much of an incumbent advantage come 2028 and thus not be an obstacle to anyone else's presidential ambitions either. Also, by being quite senior it means that his departure from the Senate will create the opportunity for those Republicans remaining in the Senate to seek better positions on committees once he is no longer filling his-everyone gets to move up. In other words: when he's gone, they get more power.

Grassley is also a good choice for Democrats because he would create a Senatorial vacancy that would now be filled by a Democratic governor. Not every state allows the governor to fill a Senate vacancy (such was the issue with replacing McConnell, because Kentucky was not one that allowed for such gubernatorial appointments), and even of the ones that do, sometimes they are limited in whom they can appoint, but Iowa is not one of these limited states. Come January the governor of Iowa will be a Democrat who can appoint another Democrat to replace Grassley.

Granted, Republicans might not be too cheerful about this prospect, losing another Senate seat and one the Democratic incumbent is likely to keep, but they would still be getting a lot out of the deal, and the substitute Senator for Grassley's seat would only have a two year term anyway, at which point a young Republican would be able to mount a challenge for it. In fact, given the results from November, which suggest Republicans would lose the seat anyway, and Grassley's incumbency, which would potentially prevent a newcomer, Republicans still are, on balance, potentially better off elevating Grassley to the Vice Presidency than not.

In sum, with a deal like this Republicans get a marginally more politically competent but unpopular incumbent in the White House, and an older one in the Vice Presidency, with new opportunity for others in the party to advance in the Senate, while Democrats get another Democratic Senator. Plus it would allow for the Cabinet to be quickly cleared out of its barbarous and/or billionaire boobs and replaced by people even marginally more competent without anyone having to spend the time and political energy individually impeaching anyone currently there (which would also be part of the deal with Vance).

And we all get rid of Trump. By January 4, even, if they all start working out the details now.

External Content
Source RSS or Atom Feed
Feed Location https://www.techdirt.com/techdirt_rss.xml
Feed Title Techdirt
Feed Link https://www.techdirt.com/
Reply 0 comments