Oh Sure, NOW Nick Clegg Tells Tech Bros They Were Wrong To Back Trump
I'm getting a bit tired of the so-called prodigal tech bros" who worked in tech companies, and only really speak out about the terrible decisions made by the leaders of those companies after they leave (at which point they get way more press coverage than anyone who has been criticizing those decisions all along). But this new piece from Nick Clegg in The Atlantic, saying that Getting Too Close to Trump Was a Mistake, feels like a new variation on the genre. Like the prodigal tech bros, his message isn't necessarily wrong, just coming way too late from a messenger who should have actually taken a stand earlier.
If you don't recall, Nick Clegg is the former UK politician (and deputy Prime Minister) who then went to Facebook/Meta, where he spent a few years as their President for Global Affairs" (effectively, second in command to Zuck) where he tended to be rolled out to take political heat for unpopular decisions. He was the one who made it clear that Zuck was willing to give up Section 230 to allow governments to regulate" Facebook... in a manner that would harm Meta's competitors way more than Meta.
He left in January of 2025 as Trump's second term was set to begin, allowing Joel Kaplan - who was way more connected to US GOP politics - to take his place. So, in some sense, it's little surprise that Clegg is now willing to throw Trump under the bus. But also, a bit late for that, Nick. Some of us were calling this shit out right away, when it was still extremely politically inconvenient to do so, rather than waiting until after the American public spoke out loud and clear during the midterms.
As for Clegg's reasoning as to why Silicon Valley's leaders lined up behind Trump, he's right that they basically got none of what they hoped to get:
First, tech leaders said that uniting the power of Washington and Silicon Valley would help America in its fight with China for AI supremacy. Yet over the past 18 months, China has been closing the gap with the United States by most objective measures, including model performance and chip development. In some important respects, China has outpaced America altogether, deploying open-weight models faster, developing a more sustainable energy strategy, and training world-class researchers and engineers at a larger scale.
Second, Silicon Valley leaders said that partnering with the government would help assuage public concerns about AI and overcome the woke" opposition to Big Tech. Yet societal attitudes toward AI in the U.S. are much more negative now than they ever were under President Biden, and worse than almost anywhere else on the planet. Fostering the very backlash they claimed they were trying to confront is a peculiar triumph of hubris and incompetence.
Third, tech executives hoped that earning Trump's good graces would allow them to avoid unwelcome regulatory incursions outside the U.S., especially in Europe. The Trump administration has undoubtedly helped with this in some ways. For example, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has become an important ally for tech leaders trying to fight a number of European Union enforcement decisions. But by any other meaningful measure the approach has been a disaster: Anti-Big Tech, and (alas) anti-American, sentiment has never been higher in large parts of the world, and most major economies-including Canada's, India's, Germany's, and Brazil's-are now scrambling to have less, not more, of what Silicon Valley produces.
Since Silicon Valley pivoted to Trump, then, its scorecard has looked something like this: chief rival (China) strengthened; domestic support weakened; global markets infuriated.
Again, though, there were plenty of people who warned about this as soon as they started up lining up behind Trump (even before the 2024 election). None of this was difficult to predict. So it seems a bit unseemly to bring all this up now.
Clegg's analysis of why they missed it so much is at least a little bit more interesting. I'm not sure I agree with them all. His first one is that they had FOMO" about Elon Musk's close relationship with Trump, and were worried that this would undercut their own company's efforts while competing with Musk's companies. I don't buy that FOMO alone explains it - the miscalculation seems so obvious that almost anyone could have seen it coming from the start.
The more interesting one to me is this one:
Payback. Tech leaders had a lot to be angry about in the run-up to Trump's reelection. Some felt unfairly treated by traditional media, academia, and cultural elites. Conservatives had long felt unwelcome in the Valley's traditionally liberal milieu. The Biden administration had clumsily vilified tech leaders rather than work with them on policy and regulation. These factors created a large group of powerful, wealthy, and offended individuals. Stepping into the Trump tent seemed like a good way to even the score.
I actually do think this was a major motivating factor among many (and have pointed that out a few times as well). But Clegg should point out how pathetic and silly this is. Tech leaders are some of the most powerful executives in the world. The fact that they got so offended that the Biden admin didn't kiss their ass is no reason to throw in with fascism. This has nothing to do with high school popularity and cliques - it's about having some fucking standards about humanity and basic rights.
On the next point, though, I do think Clegg is spot on:
Misunderstanding politics. As someone who spent nearly two decades in elected office and has spent much of my time since working in and around tech, I am always struck by how eagerly smart and wealthy people expound on subjects about which they know very little-especially politics. Their commercial success seems to foster in them a view that politics is easy, if only dim-witted officeholders would listen to them. It is this hubris that makes the Valley such an exhilarating and exasperating place.
I don't think this is necessarily limited to tech bros. Indeed, I don't think it's necessarily limited to the wealthy. Lots of people have very strong (often ill-informed) opinions on lots of things. The real problem is that with the ultra wealthy, people feel a ridiculous obligation to take their brain farts on other subjects seriously. That's where the mistakes come in. This is compounded by the assumption that because tech bros create magical-seeming innovations, they must also have special insight into policy and the future. I'm as critical as anyone of politicians not understanding tech, but the same is true in the other direction, where people in tech tend to have a very confused and unrealistic understanding of politics.
But a big part of the problem is that people take the stupid policy ideas from the tech bros seriously because of their wealth and the fact that they once lucked into selling some random business for hundreds of millions of dollars. And it seems like many of the tech bros assumed - incorrectly - that the public adulation they had received for years for their innovations would follow them into the realm of politics.
The reality is the reverse has happened. As they've embraced fascism and Trumpism, rather than having the public come along with them, the public (especially younger people) no longer trust them at all. Embracing Trumpism completely burned bridges with young Americans:

But again, this turn of events shouldn't have been a surprise. Innovators were celebrated when they focused on making people's lives better, and actually empowering them. But over the last decade, the leaders of the field, the same ones who lined up behind Donald Trump, seemed to totally ignore how the public's views regarding their own platforms had shifted. And that's because they had shifted from an era of actually empowering people to one of extracting as much as they could from them, and then demanding more.
The innovations no longer seemed cool and interesting and empowering. They seemed needy and aggressive and extractive.
Clegg's piece is frustrating in that there are elements of it that are absolutely accurate. But it comes way too late and in too weak a form. As I said right after the election, much of Silicon Valley is actually working on unique and useful innovations and doesn't support the fascist MAGA project. But too many of the CEOs and the VCs decided to buy in, and now they're going to face blowback. My fear is that the blowback directed at the shitty leaders of shitty companies will actually do more damage to the underlying internet that people still rely on, rather than just narrowly targeting the actual bad actors.
While Clegg admits that Democrats in Congress are likely to investigate the tech industry for their coziness with Trump, he misses the larger point: the blast radius of those investigations will go beyond just those companies that embraced what they thought was a fascist cheat code to dominance. It's going to make it much harder for the actual innovation, the smaller companies, and the new services that actually empower people, to exist as well. The end result is going to be a lockdown on the wider industry, because a few shithead leaders of the biggest companies couldn't think just a few steps into the future.
There's real collateral damage from the tech bros' embrace of fascism, and avoiding it starts with not sugarcoating what a mess this was all along - and discussing directly how much damage their embrace of Trumpist fascism will do to the good parts of the internet.