FCC walks back router update ban before it bricks America's network security

America's telco regulator has seen some sense over its ban on foreign-made routers, deciding that existing devices should continue receiving software and firmware updates after all. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has extended waivers covering certain foreign-made routers (and drones) already operating in the US, pushing the update deadline to at least January 1, 2029. Without the extension, updates would have been blocked as early as 2027. Back in March, the FCC updated its Covered List to include all foreign-made consumer routers, prohibiting the approval of any new models. This effectively banned any new kit made in other countries from being sold, but did not prevent the import, sale, or use of existing models that had previously been authorized. The policy stems from fears that foreign-made router pose a security threat. Because they handle network traffic, they could introduce vulnerabilities exploitable against critical infrastructure, and in the words of the FCC represent "a severe cybersecurity risk that could harm Americans." Miscreants have exploited security flaws in routers to disrupt networks or steal intellectual property, and routers are implicated in the Volt, Flax, and Salt Typhoon cyberattacks. The policy was widely regarded as flawed, not just because the vast majority of consumer router kit is made outside the US or built from components sourced abroad, but because vulnerabilities and security flaws are not limited to any particular geography, and appear in products from all brands and countries of origin, as noted by the Global Electronics Association (GEA). Blocking firmware updates, which typically deliver security patches for newly discovered flaws, also seemed a peculiar own goal for a regulator whose stated motivation is reducing network vulnerability. The FCC has belatedly recognized this, stating that its policies would have "had the effect of prohibiting permissive changes to the UAS, UAS critical components, and routers added to the Covered List in December and March. "This prohibition would be in effect even for Class I and Class II permissive changes - such as software and firmware security updates that mitigate harm to US consumers - because previously authorized UAS, UAS critical components, and routers are now covered equipment." The waivers now run until at least until January 1, 2029, falling into the final month of the Trump administration, when there is a chance this may be overlooked in the preparations for Trump's successor. The FCC extension was met with some approval. Doc McConnell, head of policy and compliance at security biz Finite State said in a supplied remark: I strongly support the FCC's decision to allow firmware and software updates for already-authorized routers, including covered devices already deployed in the United States." The biggest practical security risk with routers is not only who made them, but whether they remain patched. When they stop receiving updates, known vulnerabilities remain exposed, attackers gain durable footholds, and consumers are left with equipment they cannot realistically secure on their own. The original restriction risked creating exactly that problem: millions of deployed routers frozen in time, unable to receive security fixes. I appreciate the FCC recognizing that preventing updates could unintentionally make Americans less safe," he added. However, as previously reported by The Register, the FCC's Conditional Approval framework explicitly requires vendors seeking approval for new routers to submit plans to establish or expand manufacturing in America, with quarterly progress updates. As stated by the GEA, The policy's logic assumes that manufacturers can and will move production to the United States." That might be an assumption too far. (R)